The Planted Tank Forum banner

Your Shrimp food recommendation

3411 Views 38 Replies 22 Participants Last post by  HD Blazingwolf
If you were only going to buy one* bag of Shrimp food, what would it be?

And more importantly WHY?


*YES, I understand a balanced diet utilizing multiple food options is an optimum feeding plan.
1 - 20 of 39 Posts
How big a bag? JK

If you are asking for brand name then I'd say BW Vigor, otherwise, if I'm to stick with one type of food, it would be spinach.
"VIGOR is a mixture of enzyme and chitosan which maintains water quality, promotes growth, coloration and moulting of juvenile and adult shrimps. You can observe that shrimps stop dying during unsuccessful molting. Vigor also helps in boosting plant growth in a planted tank."

Sounds good up to that last sentence??? What is in this stuff that will be boosting my plant growth?
Repashy, repashy, repashy, repashy.

Rachel has a long thread of people singing the praises -- With lots of the technical reasons this stuff rocks (primarily -- disintigrates VERY slowly in water, on the order of 36 hours, yet is the consistency of Jello so even baby shrimp can munch on it. Plant based binding agents that are edible -- No filler! Etc.)

The shrimp souffle is pretty well formulated with additional calcium.

Nothing else I've fed my fish or shrimp makes all of them go nuts like this stuff does.

Seeing Otos and Corys go into a massive feeding frenzy is a thing to behold.

The biggest thing is livestock can graze on this stuff in a way that they can't on any other foods. It takes a minimum of 24 hours for it to turn to mush, so they can pick at it at their leisure.

You can mash it into drift wood or onto rocks if you want. It is versatile because of the the fact that it is a gel.

It keeps for ever since you can mix up how ever much of the powder that you want.

You can mix the powders to vary diet -- We mix in Soilent Green to add more spirulina to their diet.

Just dropped a small piece into the shrimp tank. This is about 1 min into the shrimp ball formation. About twice the size now...

Mix of Malawa and Blue Pearl with a greedy Amano in the front. -- My pics are terrible, sorry :(
See less See more
I would get frenzi and feed vegetables.

BUT:

I would never need to buy just one bag anymore if H4n is around. I buy 10-12 lil baggies of high end food for a very good price shipped. :)

Ask him for details: http://mail.plantedtank.net/forums/member.php?u=6583
Shirakura! Back to the basics!!! My shrimps crave it. Has pretty much everything they need and comes in a big bag that lasts a while.
I'm offering Mulberry leaves and there is a rich bio-film on the cholla & sponge filter, also some Java fern & taiwan moss in the tank I have my new group of CRS in. They are all juv.size.

When I had Cherry shrimp they were in a planted tank and offered them worm flakes or spiurella flakes 2Xs a week to supplement the natural food in the tank. They also had a Mulberry leave from time to time. They did well on that program.

I'm running low on fish food, I buy those from a vendor at a club Swap meet. So , before I buy more I thought I'd look into Shrimp specific food.

All the major brands have a wide selection and they have their own twist on the same basic ideas. Your personal reasons are helpful to get me past the Marketing hype when I read about these foods.

I know several of the people here that sell shrimp food, some I consider friends. I would prefer to keep this thread about the food and not the sellers. I shop here 1st so who I buy from isn't a issue.

Comments about growth rates, coloration, breeding, interest in eating etc. are most helpful.

Thanks to those that have contributed so far.
See less See more
I actually would split the diet in two types (non brand specific) if given a choice.

1. calcium enriched pellets
2. protein enriched pellets

1 is key at a dietary staple for all invertebrates and a necessity for proper molting
2 is important as a supplement as the lack there of will force them to be cannibalistic. sad but true.
From the OP
...
*YES, I understand a balanced diet utilizing multiple food options is an optimum feeding plan.


acitydweller - Please I'd really like to stay on Topic.

Do you have a single product line recommendation and a rational behind that choice to contribute?
If I had to choose just two:
BorneoWild Grow
BorneoWild Color

Here is my routine:
BorneoWild Color
BorneoWild Grow
BorneoWild Stout
BorneoWild Barley
Shirakura Baby Food
Indian Almond Leaf (stays in tank until it breaks down)
agreed on that repashy! If you get it and don't like having to have the gel in the fridge, throw it in the dehydrater after making the gel. Makes perfect pellet/thingies that are just like the expensive foods you buy. LOVE that stuff.
I don't have it yet, but Repashy Shrimp Souffle. I've read so many good things about it and if Rachel (Msjinkzd) says it's amazing, then I'm all over it. I just don't have any spare money right now.

-Lisa
From the OP

acitydweller - Please I'd really like to stay on Topic.

Do you have a single product line recommendation and a rational behind that choice to contribute?
Shirakura would be my choice. Balanced nutrients without having to buy a dozen types of foods like Borneo wild.I own all the BW products so this comes from experience.
Snails just one crunch against the glass and you have the perfect food, and it contains every vitamin mineral and protein that shrimp need to survive and thrive . The perfect food at the perfect price . Ok course natural food grown in the tank is also near perfect but unless the stocking density is very low likely not enough will be produced . Repashy sound's very nice as well but when price must be considered not for me . Question why would you only want 1 food ? I feed at least 10 different types . Or is it simply for this disscusion and hypothetical ?
Nevermind I did not input Buy and Bag as well as the side note
Aside from my own foods, for obvious selfish reasons, I'd get the cheapest algae wafers you can find at your LFS. Why? Cost. To go even cheaper, generic algae flakes are also a great option.

Repashy is great and I sing its praises. Just beware the amount of protein in everything - including the new (and amazing) Super Green - if you're not feeding anything else to supplement the diet. (Repashy = only food I've ever used that's helped my Otos spawn)
When you buy small amounts of Repashy, it is expensive. It doesn't get cheaper in a linear fashion though, it gets cheaper much more quickly.

Snails just one crunch against the glass and you have the perfect food, and it contains every vitamin mineral and protein that shrimp need to survive and thrive . The perfect food at the perfect price . Ok course natural food grown in the tank is also near perfect but unless the stocking density is very low likely not enough will be produced . Repashy sound's very nice as well but when price must be considered not for me . Question why would you only want 1 food ? I feed at least 10 different types . Or is it simply for this disscusion and hypothetical ?


^^ That and some cheap algae wafers for protein and you're set.
Do you blanche or just feed raw?
1 - 20 of 39 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top