I'm not saying that
it is that particular product however, let's not get TPT into any trouble there, it seems that owner, Carl is very sensitive towards the very customers that might buy his product and has threaten sue many aquarium hobbyists and forum owners if you say bad things about his product.
We cannot do that and should not approach it that way.
Committing torts against a company is not wise.
If you are prepared to go down that path, that's up to you, I did and won.
Not everyone did.
The James Randi Educational Foundation (
http://www.randi.org ) has $1,000,000 waiting for anyone that can show in a double-blind test that water has any measurable difference once the magnetic fields have been removed. So far, not one person has been able to show anything.
I mean if it really does what they claim, why not get the 1,000,000$?
Why make them for the aquarium industry if it really does what is claimed?
Here's a discussion about a "similar" device:
http://reefcentral.com/forums/showt...rpage=25&highlight=eco aqualizer&pagenumber=1
Pay attention particularly to Randy's thought process. I'm less concerned about this product, which is "similar", but more concerned with the general process and discussion. There are few Randy's in the planted arena sadly
He critical, no more than myself, a bit nicer than I generally too
Enjoy reading though.
Many of same forum poster arguments on the pro side that come up for ADA, for "Algae cure alls" and various other new products that make claims are present in this tread and maybe applied here.
Sadly, many folks fall prey to same thought processes displayed in the RC thread.
I would hope folks, myself included(see ADA and rashes), will be a bit more critical about various products. I concede that the ADA AS may not cause the rash, but it was hard to rule out also and under the rather unusual circumstances I used it under, it is not an issue I am concerned about.
But I admitted it, unlike many who are ego and pride driven.
Now some are running around saying ADA As causes rashes and should they buy it or not.:icon_mad:
Regards,
Tom Barr