The Planted Tank Forum banner
1 - 4 of 4 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
89 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I am about to preorder a bunch of this stuff. I like how it’s lower in ammonia than Amazonia and has great reviews. I especially love it comes in black and won’t scratch my expensive acrylic tank.

But it’s very expensive for my 60 gallon, I’ll need about $300.00 worth. And very hard to get, UNS reps told me a new batch is coming mid September and then not for a while after that.

My question - Anyone use this and will it break down to mud? And how long? I’m fine with 3 years but 1 year isn’t worth the price IMO. I know I’ll have to eventually dose as nutrients run out but I’m most concerned about it turning to mush.

Any other input from anyone who uses it likes/dislikes and really aqua soils in general feel free to post!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
79 Posts
I currently have the Controsoil in my UNS 60U and it works really well for growing plants. I am planning to rescape in the next week or so from my first scape of the tank done in March. I am worried about it turning to mud just from rescaping. It seems pretty soft (after just 5 months), and it is very easy to crush between my fingers. I don't have long term experience with it so I can't comment on it maintaining its structure for long periods of time, but replanting and moving hardscape seems to break it down pretty easily. It is unfortunate because it works so well with the plants and it is expensive.

My advice would be go for it if you are dedicated to keeping the hardscape relatively static for a long period of time and you don't uproot and move plants too frequently. It really is a nice aquarium soil. If I can remember to I will update with the results of the rescape that will require removing the soil from the tank.

-AM
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
89 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·
I currently have the Controsoil in my UNS 60U and it works really well for growing plants. I am planning to rescape in the next week or so from my first scape of the tank done in March. I am worried about it turning to mud just from rescaping. It seems pretty soft (after just 5 months), and it is very easy to crush between my fingers. I don't have long term experience with it so I can't comment on it maintaining its structure for long periods of time, but replanting and moving hardscape seems to break it down pretty easily. It is unfortunate because it works so well with the plants and it is expensive.

My advice would be go for it if you are dedicated to keeping the hardscape relatively static for a long period of time and you don't uproot and move plants too frequently. It really is a nice aquarium soil. If I can remember to I will update with the results of the rescape that will require removing the soil from the tank.

-AM
Nice thanks for the info. Do you have hard water or use RO going in? You confirmed a lot of my thoughts. I have tap that comes out at 8.0 and very hard I feel that’s going to speed up the breakdown quite a bit since it will be buffering it a lot.

I do actually plan to have a static scape. Goo luck with your rescape, I hear that’s a struggle with Controsoil. I love the look of it. Read that if you vacuum after moving stuff around and get up what breaks down and replace it, it works well. Replacing a little at a time wouldn’t break the bank.

I don’t mind going eco complete, don’t mind dosing, but don’t want the acrylic scratches. Maybe I’ll just do straight up gravel after all.
 
1 - 4 of 4 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top