The Planted Tank Forum banner

Shrimp safe chemicals?

831 Views 7 Replies 4 Participants Last post by  wood
I have some RCS and I'm about to get some CRS in one of my beautiful planted tanks.

I really want to add some ferst but I heard that there are some ferts and other chemicals that can hurt inverts.

so far I have seachem's prime, flourish, and flourish excel but i'm afraid that it could harm them so i never used them yet.

can u guys give me a list of ferts and other chemicals that u used so far that are safe?

maybe we can make this a sticky
1 - 8 of 8 Posts
I heard that there are some ferts and other chemicals that can hurt inverts.
maybe if you wrote about what you heard
instead of what you already use, we can
address your specific concerns.

generally, shrimp are sensitive to sudden change,
so anything you use gradually and in moderation
should be fine.

some avoid CSM+B powders known to include copper.
always avoid so called algae destroying chemicals.

usually, threads that become stickied
are started and moderated by someone
consolidating a solution within a thread,
not just asking a question that a few
minutes of searching could answer :icon_roll
See less See more
Ouch, spypet. LOL.

I use Prime works well with shrimp. I've also used Flourish and Excel without any problems. However, do NOT try any Excel OD tricks.

I've also dosed dry ferts (NPK) and CSM+B without noticing any bad effects on my shrimp. I have to point out that I under-dose these chemicals in my shrimp tank.
maybe if you wrote about what you heard
instead of what you already use, we can
address your specific concerns.

generally, shrimp are sensitive to sudden change,
so anything you use gradually and in moderation
should be fine.

some avoid CSM+B powders known to include copper.
always avoid so called algae destroying chemicals.

usually, threads that become stickied
are started and moderated by someone
consolidating a solution within a thread,
not just asking a question that a few
minutes of searching could answer :icon_roll
I did tell u. i said people have told me ferts are not good for shrimp.

i'm sorry if i googled anti shrimp chemicals don't come up with results.

i just wanted to see so far if experiences with different chemicals are harmful to shrimp so it was nice to see it from personal experience of other fish keepers. so i thought it would be nice if we can get a list of things so far safe for others to see.

i don't get it spypet, is there something u have against me? like last time with the micro lobsters. what is this negative feeling ur giving off? is there something u want to tell me?

BTW epicfish, thanks for assuring me that i can use prime and excel.
thanks wood that really helped alot. man next time im just gonna go to ur site. i should have know planetinvert had everything about shrimp. lol
wood, your KNO3 observations are interesting,
especially how they pertain to smaller tanks. my
nitrates are naturally 5-10ppm, so I never end
up dosing any, but it's good to know for future,
when I get compressed Co2 and my plants may
end up hungry for additional macros, so thanks.
wood, your KNO3 observations are interesting,
especially how they pertain to smaller tanks. my
nitrates are naturally 5-10ppm, so I never end
up dosing any, but it's good to know for future,
when I get compressed Co2 and my plants may
end up hungry for additional macros, so thanks.
Yea shrimp are sensitive to nitrates and do not like them. Change the tank water and test the nitrate levels after changing the water. Then test a week later right before changing it again. If the level goes up then you know that the plants are not starved. If it goes down then you know that the plants are using some of it. If it is zero then you know that they might be starved. Look at the plant conditions if you feel they may be starved.

If you feel that the plants are starved make sure that you are very careful dosing KNO3. Dose very little at a time and test the water. You should be able to achieve the right amount to dose without harming your shrimp or starving your plants at the same time if you test properly.

Remember that changing the water in the tank is the "control" so that you know what you started with after you changed the water the first time. You must test the water right before changing the water the next time. Test a few times after and before changes so that you can know an average amount of nitrate consumption.
See less See more
1 - 8 of 8 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top