The Planted Tank Forum banner
1 - 15 of 15 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
132 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Needless to say, despite my best efforts, I really hate this tank. And I would like some advice on rescaping it. The problem I ran into is that it's too narrow for almost everything and the length just adds to the difficulty of creating something that's pleasant to look at. So anyone have some ideas? I have tons of spare dwarf hair grass and two pots of marsilea minuta left. I'm thinking of selling off the rocks and getting a bunch of tiny ones to replace them.

 

·
Registered
Joined
·
271 Posts
I think thew only real problem with this layout is the slope. If you had a more gradual incline it would look far more natural, it would also help with the sense of depth if you lower the front and slope up towards the back of the tank
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,691 Posts
looks like you had the right idea but backwards. the scene looks like we are looking from behind the mountain rather than the front of it.
scapes should never be high in the front, unless you were going after something specific.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
132 Posts
Discussion Starter · #4 ·
Trouble I had was because its so narrow. The slope would have been too steep and the rocks looked out of place because of the sharp incline. It needed to be more gradual. That all being said, now that the carpet has a root system I may be able to pul them up and scoop out the substrate and replant just to see. Can't be any worse. :)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,691 Posts
i know what you mean but that's part of scaping. creating the illusion of it being a larger space than it really is. i think you have the right idea. maybe transplant some carpeting and shift the rocks towards the back for start.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
619 Posts
Don't worry, I replaced my rocks a couple of time after the tank was planted... It's a PITA! I'm still not 100% satisfied with my scape and to this day am collecting stones that I think will fit for my next incarnation of this tank. But don't give up on this.

Check out the 12G Rimless Club, If you haven't already.

BTW, Your 20L looks great! Good luck.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
733 Posts
Nice carpet, and those rocks have potential!

Check out the link in my signature to see my 12g Long, it is currently dry starting. It might give you some ideas of how to rescape your tank, let me know what ya think.

What filter are you using with yours?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
132 Posts
Discussion Starter · #8 ·
Don't worry, I replaced my rocks a couple of time after the tank was planted... It's a PITA! I'm still not 100% satisfied with my scape and to this day am collecting stones that I think will fit for my next incarnation of this tank. But don't give up on this.

Check out the 12G Rimless Club, If you haven't already.

BTW, Your 20L looks great! Good luck.
Thanks!

Nice carpet, and those rocks have potential!

Check out the link in my signature to see my 12g Long, it is currently dry starting. It might give you some ideas of how to rescape your tank, let me know what ya think.

What filter are you using with yours?
You need more plants. :)

It's a Finnex PX-360. Seems to be working well.

Just finished redoing the tank a bit. Thankfully the marsilea minuta had quite the thick root system making it easier to replant and make "mats". I'll snap a pic of it once it's clear.





All this is left over:





Also removed two Akadama stones:

 

·
Registered
Joined
·
744 Posts
When I first glanced it I immediately thought your look would be completed with some nice tall Vals in the back side of both corners. As long as you keep them to the back and run allong the back wall, I think the rocks will look fabulous just as they are right now! Give it a try! They might give just what you were looking for :) If it doesn't work...you can always try to rescape a bit. But I really encourage you to try Vals first. Maybe even have them turn the corner following the glass on the sides of the tank...just a touch though not allowing the to go beyond the first 1/4 of the side glass.

After looking at the last picture with the plants filled in and a bit taller...maybe even try the Vals on the Left side first...maybe leaving the right side open like a "meadow".

Good luck! :proud:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
271 Posts
Better I think. Even made $25 off of part of the carpet I ripped out. :)




I may ended up ripping out all of the hairgrass and replace it with marsilea. Also those two largest rocks in the middle and on the left need to go.
Beautiful, I would consider making the carpet transition more diagonal so you aren't looking down it. I think that would increase the sense of depth, soften the transition and allow you to weed out a channel if one plant was invading the other. Other than that I think continuing to fiddle with it is risky, its so easy to keep changing things until you ruin it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
132 Posts
Discussion Starter · #14 ·
When I first glanced it I immediately thought your look would be completed with some nice tall Vals in the back side of both corners. As long as you keep them to the back and run allong the back wall, I think the rocks will look fabulous just as they are right now! Give it a try! They might give just what you were looking for :) If it doesn't work...you can always try to rescape a bit. But I really encourage you to try Vals first. Maybe even have them turn the corner following the glass on the sides of the tank...just a touch though not allowing the to go beyond the first 1/4 of the side glass.

After looking at the last picture with the plants filled in and a bit taller...maybe even try the Vals on the Left side first...maybe leaving the right side open like a "meadow".

Good luck! :proud:
Not familiar with "Vals?"

Beautiful, I would consider making the carpet transition more diagonal so you aren't looking down it. I think that would increase the sense of depth, soften the transition and allow you to weed out a channel if one plant was invading the other. Other than that I think continuing to fiddle with it is risky, its so easy to keep changing things until you ruin it.
It's hard to see, but I planted some hairgrass in a diagonal in front near the edges of the marsilea to help make the transition seem more "natural".

wow this looks way better. it would be cool if you let the two carpets mix together and then added some Vesuvius swords along the center slope

They will eventually (and already are in some parts). I had dividers in the substate before I planted to stop the hairgrass from taking over the tank like it did in my 20g. Since hairgrass sends runners from below first where the marsilea goes from the top, it should be more manageable in the future I hope. The hairgrass will also be trimmed with maybe 10mm sticking up above the substrate after it fills in completely, should be a nice effect.
 
1 - 15 of 15 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top