The Planted Tank Forum banner

RCS wild color

3780 Views 38 Replies 14 Participants Last post by  TNUTT8089
Anyone have a picture of the "wild" "natural" or what ever the color is that the RCS turn into. Also is it true that you want to cull these or move them to a difference tank to prevent the gene from spreading.
1 - 20 of 39 Posts
I'm sure someone will correct me if I'm wrong. This is one of two females I have. Some people call them "Natty Browns", "Black" or "Chocolate" Cherries. From what I've read and seen, I think they're the wild strain of the Red Cherry Shrimp. You can just barely see the golden brown stripe down the middle of her back like Cherries get. Sometimes they're very red, especially if you turn the lights on at night after the tank has been dark a while. Sometimes they're light brown. Usually they're just like the picture during the day.



Tommy <9))>>{
See less See more
ok well ive got one that looks more green then brown and am wondering if this is the wild color or a color variation. I didnt notice it in time and it has laid eggs about a month ago and i think i have seen some babies that are this greenish clolor. Just need to know if i should remove or let it be.
3
Well this is what Ive found in my tank. More green then brown. Is it a green shrimp that got mixed in my shipment or a color morph.




See less See more
That is a very good question; for those of you who sell RCS: in your experience, do LFS's buy RCS that are not red?
well i have only bought them from 2 sellers here on pt.
I agree with Tommy. I'm no expert, but I've been trying to answer this very question for myself and, after much online research, that's what I came up with ~ "Natty Browns" or "Chocolate" shrimp are the wild form. And they also look just like the pic he's posted.

As far as your pictured shrimp, Kunerd ~ I'd guess that either the person that sold them to you also kept yellow cherries and gave you a "bonus" or it's just something that's spontaneously shown up from your red cherries. When did you first notice it and how long have you had your cherries? Long enough for that one to have been born from them?
Anyone? I am curious about whether or not LFS's accept these, because my shrimp are berried and I would like very much to start selling shrimp to fund this hobby :D
do these shrimp cross-breed?
i bought a rcs package in march and noticed its color but it was so small i paid not attention to it. I didn't really start focusing on it till about a month ago because of it size now. I did see it berried once with brown/greenish eggs and i am starting to see little ones that looked like it did when i first got it. but they could still be young though. You think i should separate it then or leave it in the 30g with the rest of the rcs
Fishscale, I have no idea. You would probably do better asking your LFS since even if someone here says their LFS takes them, that's no guarantee yours will.


Retoid, the wild form of cherry will cross with RCS and yellow cherries. There may be more they will cross with, but I don't have enough experience or knowledge to say which. I do know they won't cross with a shrimp of another genus, such as Crystal Reds, Wood Shrimp or Amanos.



If I were you, Kunerd, I'd definitely separate it and the others that look like it. I wouldn't get rid of them, though ~ I'd keep breeding them and see what comes of it. That's exactly how red cherries and other different colors of cherry shrimp came about ~ someone noticed a morph, a shrimp of a different color, in their tank and bred them out. Of course stabilizing the strain takes many generations through which you'll have to keep a close eye on the tank, culling any reds out and keeping two lines of them in two separate tanks so you can interbreed later and avoid genetic problems. If you have any questions about that, let me know ~ I'd be glad to tell you all I know about that.

If you don't have enough room for another shrimp-only tank or two and/or don't want to mess with them, I'll trade you a bunch of young Red Cherries for them. And maybe sweeten the deal with first dibs on a few if you want some back once I get them to reproduce (IF I can get them to reproduce AND they end up being something interesting)? Let me know. Regardless, I wouldn't get rid of them until I knew what they'd produce in future generations. You never know what will come of them unless you try it. :)
See less See more
[/URL][/IMG]its a wild form, get it out asap and put it in another tank or more and more less than red shrimp will start showing up. they are sold as feeders here and i use them in my planted tank only because i cant get rid of them. they will vary in color from clear, to tiger striped to yellow, reddish or even a chocolate brown. color is NOT permanent like a RCS and will change with the environment the shrimp is in at the time. its not a Yellow shrimp like those being sold now, that color is permanent like the Red form. they are all the same species though so make sure they dont mix or you'll enventually end up with all wild form in the future.
See less See more
[/URL][/IMG]its a wild form, get it out asap and put it in another tank or more and more less than red shrimp will start showing up. they are sold as feeders here and i use them in my planted tank only because i cant get rid of them. they will vary in color from clear, to tiger striped to yellow, reddish or even a chocolate brown. color is NOT permanent like a RCS and will change with the environment the shrimp is in at the time. its not a Yellow shrimp like those being sold now, that color is permanent like the Red form. they are all the same species though so make sure they dont mix or you'll enventually end up with all wild form in the future.

yes but mine are greenish and i havent read anywhere that they turn green when reverting to wild color
that kind of looks like the so called "rainbow"shrimp I bought. I would remove it and any other shrimp that look like it. Or your CRS will no longer be considered pure and you will have hybrids in your tank. Most people don't want hybrids.
Cindy
"yes but mine are greenish and i havent read anywhere that they turn green when reverting to wild color"

they come in almost all colors, i have several dozen that greenish color right now. a large batch of these will look like several different shrimp varieties because of the various color morphs.
DHavoc, are you talking about the wild cherries? They come in all colors? I thought they were only brown with maybe slight tinges of another color? I'm no expert, so would love more info. Do you know of a reputable site with info and pics on the for-sure-definite wild form?
I've just recently read that Red is a colour morph, and that wild RCS are actually brownish, and that they are never actually red in the wild. Not sure if it's true or not though.
I was just on vacation in cali and went to a lfs in chinatown selling "cherry shrimp" but these were not red at all but were instead a clearish color like the one posted. it had little to no brown on its body at all.
1 - 20 of 39 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top