The Planted Tank Forum banner

My First Planted tank (10g)

3419 Views 30 Replies 10 Participants Last post by  Clavius
Hello all,

I've been in the Saltwater/Reef aquarium hobby for about 2 years. At the moment I have a 34g Solana setup for nearly a year now. You can check it out here if you're interested. Anyway, I'm looking for a new challenge. And planted tanks look like that next challenge. I'm blown away by some of the planted tanks on this site and hope that I can set up a tank that is half decent. I've decided to get started with a 10g tank that I had sitting around. It's a small tank, but it's really all I have room for at the moment. Here's the rest of the equipment that I currently have:

-Marineland Hood/Single Fluorescent Light combo
-Aquaclear 20 filter
-100w Stealth Pro heater (a little overkill for a 10g, but PetSmart was out of the 50w)
-CaribSea Flora Max Planted Aquarium Substrate

Any thoughts/suggestions?
1 - 20 of 31 Posts
You will have a low light tank with a single strip bulb. Which is fine but limits the amount of plants that you can grow.
You will have a low light tank with a single strip bulb. Which is fine but limits the amount of plants that you can grow.
Yeah, I figured that would be the case. It's just hard to find a nice 20" light. Will I be able to grow any interesting plants with the single fluorescent light?
Sure! I believe theres a sticky on this forum of low light plants. Look through it and decide what you like the looks of.
Sure! I believe theres a sticky on this forum of low light plants. Look through it and decide what you like the looks of.
Awesome! I found it. Thank you.
So I bought a cheap Marineland hood with a single fluorescent bulb for like $30 at Petsmart. I figured this would be enough light to do something with. But now I'm having second thoughts and am considering taking it back. For one, I don't think I like the look of the hood at all. I prefer open top tanks and would run my reef tank open top if I didn't have to worry about fish jumping out. So now I'm considering this option. I don't think it's a high-light solution but I'm thinking it may be better than the single fluorescent option I currently have. Plus, it would allow me to run the tank without a top. Which I would really like to do. Any thoughts?
Only 9w of light and lacking in the red wavelength output. Im absolutely no expert but personally I would probably look for something that runs T5HO bulbs instead...
Only 9w of light and lacking in the red wavelength output. Im absolutely no expert but personally I would probably look for something that runs T5HO bulbs instead...
Yeah, I guess I'd be better off with the fluorescent I have than that particular LED setup. I'd love to run T5HO over the tank but the trouble is finding a 20" fixture. Current USA used to have 20" T5 fixtures but they stopped making them. The only other lighting solution that I can think of for this tank is a PAR38.
Alright, I did a little more research on trying to find a 20" T5HO light for this tank. And I think I may have found something that will work. It's only 18" long but is 36w of T5HO light. Only problem is it is the saltwater version. Not exactly what I'm looking for but I'm thinking I can just replace the actinic lamp with another daylight lamp. Do you guys think this would work?
I think I'm going to stick with the single strip fluorescent that I already have. For now, at least. My reef tank is high-tech I guess you could say. And it's the tank I devote most of my time to. So after reading more about the low-tech/light tanks I think that is going to be my plan of action with this planted tank. I can't have two high-maintenance tanks. That would just be overload. Anyway, I think I may have found a stand for the 10g tank. A fellow reefer has one.
Yeah, a T5HO is a very bad idea for a 10g. A T5NO would be a better option. Or purchasing another strip. Or trying an under the cabinet light from a big box store.
In addition to chad320's suggestions, with my 10 (when it was still up and running) I used two of those little clamp lights you can find at hardware stores and 15 watt spiral CFLs. I gutted an old reptile hood and put them in there so it was aesthetically pleasing, but that's not necessary. Dirt cheap and all it took was some DIY co2 and occasional ferts to keep algae at bay. Just offering another option if you decide to go higher light.

Also, hello fellow Kentuckian!
In addition to chad320's suggestions, with my 10 (when it was still up and running) I used two of those little clamp lights you can find at hardware stores and 15 watt spiral CFLs. I gutted an old reptile hood and put them in there so it was aesthetically pleasing, but that's not necessary. Dirt cheap and all it took was some DIY co2 and occasional ferts to keep algae at bay. Just offering another option if you decide to go higher light.

Also, hello fellow Kentuckian!
Thanks for the suggestion! But I think I'm going to keep this tank as low tech as possible. For two reasons, I'm still learning and I need to keep my main focus on my reef tank because I have so much invested in it. This planted tank is kind of a side project. But I hope to be successful with it. I'm going to pick up a stand for the tank tomorrow and will be placing an order online for some supplies to get this tank up and running. I still haven't decided if I'm going to use straight tap water or RO/DI water for this planted tank... I'm leaning towards tap because the RO/DI wastes a lot of water so I kind of want to use it only for my reef tank.

Here's a shot of the tank sitting on a box... exciting!

See less See more
Ah yes, I read that. I just wanted to throw it out there for future reference.

And of course it's exciting! It's a new tank! Keep us posted.
2
Finally got my hands on a stand for the tank!



See less See more
I decided to exchange the Perfecto/Marineland light & hood combo for a glass top and separate lighting fixture (ironically it cost me MORE to do it this way). I did so after reading here that the light/hood combo restricted the amount of light that got to the front of the tank. Also, having the glass hinged top will allow me to upgrade my lighting in the future should I ever decide to do so.

See less See more
3
That hood style lighting is only rated for 15-17W of power and the light quality is not very good for plant growth. Here is a cheap solution for your lighting that has worked great for planted tanks.

Find a local appliance store that sells clip on desk lamp that is rated for 60W. They are usually only about $5-9. Make sure you get one the works for you setup. Mine is next to something I can clip on. They have variations, but this is what I'm talking about:



Next get a 6700K 20W CF bulb (this is rated at 75W for normal bulb but won't overheat). You can get these at Target and some other places for less than $5. 6700K is the brightness or luminance of the light. The higher the number the whiter and better quality the light output is. To grow healthy plants you'll need at least 6000K of luminance.

You'll end up with something like my tank. This is my 10G tank with a cheap clip on 60W lamp stand and a 20W 6700K CF bulb (I got both at Target):




*Check out my 10g setup for more pictures*

This should be plenty of light for a 10G. You can see how bright it gets, and the plants love it. The best part is that it will only cost you around $12-15 total and will output much better quality light then that hooded lamp you have.

If you have any more questions let me know. I've done several cheap DIY aquarium methods that work just as good or better than their full priced counterparts.
See less See more
Many thanks for your help Superluminal. But if I were to setup a fixture with increased lighting wouldn't I have to supplement it by adding CO2?
Many thanks for your help Superluminal. But if I were to setup a fixture with increased lighting wouldn't I have to supplement it by adding CO2?
You don't have to, but I recommend it. Naturally, with more light your plants are going to take in more CO2 and release more oxygen as a byproduct. This can lower the CO2 content in the tank and cause the plants to grow slower. I run a cheap DIY CO2 (yeast/sugar method). It's as simple as a 2 liter bottle, some nylon tubing, and a nano diffuser.

Many times after the yeast stops producing CO2, I'm too lazy to change the bottle. I just notice that my plants grow slower without the CO2.

You can make a DIY CO2 system for practically free if you have most of the items in your house. You can get a diffuser(s) on eBay for around $6.

I had to buy some supplies, so my DIY CO2 cost about $12 for everything, including the sugar, yeast, and nano diffuser. I had everything else already.
1 - 20 of 31 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top