The Planted Tank Forum banner

1 - 20 of 31 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,108 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I plan to put Dwarf Sag the entire front of my tank, it 6 feet. Then have some Micro Sword I plan to put around rocks and fill in with it. Or will that be to much? I was going to get half/square foot, but thinking that might be overkill. This is for 125, Maybe I should avoid the micro sword all together?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
140 Posts
Dwarf Sag is an odd choice for a foreground. By using Microsword in the true foreground and using Sag in the midground, you can create a much more complex scape. Maybe go half half?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,994 Posts
Knowing the history of that tank I'd suggest you limit the plant Sp. and choose the toughest of the tough. Of these two I would suggest the Dwarf Sag.

Same with the Swords, pick 2-3 sp. maybe different leave shapes to give varity. Get this monster tank going strong. Then start introducing other plants. Try to match requirements as close as you can in your selections.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,108 Posts
Discussion Starter · #4 ·
So here what I am thinking for plants. I have one time to get this right, if plants die it be long time before I can get any plants again. Also won't be able to really add more plants in say 2 months from now. Once the first round of money spent on it, I am done with spending on it. Least that what I have been told ha ha. Also wanted the tank to be planted very heavy so that why such high number of stuff.

Dwarf Sagittaria - 60
Narrow Leaf Sagittaria - 60
Dwarf Amazon Sword Plant - 6
Rosette Sword Plant - 8
Amazon Swords - 4
Red Melon Sword - 3
Vallisneria spiralis - 60
Anubias barteri v. Nana - 4
Anubias, Barteri Broad Leaf - 4
Tiger lotus red – 3
Tiger lotus green -3
Micro Sword (Lilaeopsis Brasiliensis) half/square
Uruguayensis Sword- 4
Red Rubin Sword - 4
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
989 Posts
Knowing the history of that tank I'd suggest you limit the plant Sp. and choose the toughest of the tough. Of these two I would suggest the Dwarf Sag.

Same with the Swords, pick 2-3 sp. maybe different leave shapes to give varity. Get this monster tank going strong. Then start introducing other plants. Try to match requirements as close as you can in your selections.
1+ from all your posts that I've read. I think I would stay as simple as possible (Kept It Simple Stupid).

Maybe I might be stepping out of the line here. But you seem to get overwhelm too quickly and quit. well, not quit but I think you make it so hard on yourself that your wife see that... which cause her to step in to make ya stop. Sometimes the your other half (wife) knows you better than you know yourself.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,108 Posts
Discussion Starter · #7 ·
1+ from all your posts that I've read. I think I would stay as simple as possible (Kept It Simple Stupid).

Maybe I might be stepping out of the line here. But you seem to get overwhelm too quickly and quit. well, not quit but I think you make it so hard on yourself that your wife see that... which cause her to step in to make ya stop. Sometimes the your other half (wife) knows you better than you know yourself.
:red_mouth
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,221 Posts
Keep it simple!

Get just one ground cover, not 2. My least fussy gc has been marsilea.
Dwarf Sagittaria - 60
Micro Sword (Lilaeopsis Brasiliensis) half/square

Either one, not both
Narrow Leaf Sagittaria - 60
Vallisneria spiralis - 60

Great mid ground plants but get 6 of 1 kind.
Dwarf Amazon Sword Plant - 6
Rosette Sword Plant - 8


Get 4 of one species not 4 different kinds
Amazon Swords - 4
Red Melon Sword - 3
Uruguayensis Sword- 4
Red Rubin Sword - 4

Choose one and get more of it.
Anubias barteri v. Nana - 4
Anubias, Barteri Broad Leaf - 4

Get one of whichever you like best not 6. They are monsters and big as your tank looks it isn't going to hold 6 happy lotus plants.
Tiger lotus red – 3
Tiger lotus green -3
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,108 Posts
Discussion Starter · #11 ·
Keep it simple!

Get just one ground cover, not 2. My least fussy gc has been marsilea.
Dwarf Sagittaria - 60
Micro Sword (Lilaeopsis Brasiliensis) half/square

Either one, not both
Narrow Leaf Sagittaria - 60
Vallisneria spiralis - 60

Great mid ground plants but get 6 of 1 kind.
Dwarf Amazon Sword Plant - 6
Rosette Sword Plant - 8


Get 4 of one species not 4 different kinds
Amazon Swords - 4
Red Melon Sword - 3
Uruguayensis Sword- 4
Red Rubin Sword - 4

Choose one and get more of it.
Anubias barteri v. Nana - 4
Anubias, Barteri Broad Leaf - 4

Get one of whichever you like best not 6. They are monsters and big as your tank looks it isn't going to hold 6 happy lotus plants.
Tiger lotus red – 3
Tiger lotus green -3
This post is very helpful, thank you.

One of the main reasons I was going with so many, is that my wife wants it planted very heavy. So I wanted to make sure it really filled up. Do you think I can still do that with making limited numbers? Or do I just still limit the type, but increase the number of that type? For example, 6 swords to fill the back of the tank?
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
989 Posts
This post is very helpful, thank you.

One of the main reasons I was going with so many, is that my wife wants it planted very heavy. So I wanted to make sure it really filled up. Do you think I can still do that with making limited numbers? Or do I just still limit the type, but increase the number of that type? For example, 6 swords to fill the back of the tank?
I think you're taking all the fun out of a planted tank. Plants do grow!!! It will it fill in over a period of time. One of the fun thing about planted tank, is watching your tank progression. If you overfilled it on day one, what are you enjoying?


You reminded me of people going into LFS, buy a cute little 2" to 3" common pleco for their 5 gallon tank. Not releasing 6 months later it got to 6" to 8" long and destroying everything in their tank. Then returning the pleco back to LFS say, 'I didn't know they get so big!".

Patient... enjoy your tank... grow with your tank... learn the art of taking care of your planted tank.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,456 Posts
This post is very helpful, thank you.

One of the main reasons I was going with so many, is that my wife wants it planted very heavy. So I wanted to make sure it really filled up. Do you think I can still do that with making limited numbers? Or do I just still limit the type, but increase the number of that type? For example, 6 swords to fill the back of the tank?
limit the type, and buy more.

If you're anything like me, it'll make it easier to keep and maintain because you're unable to keep up with the maintenance of a million different plants and their requirements and growth rates.

you'll end up with a more cohesive natural looking tank that, i think, everyone will be happy with.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,108 Posts
Discussion Starter · #16 ·
Thanks everyone for the advise, now trying to narrow the list down.

Few more questions.
Tiger Lotus, is 3 still too many or should I do away with it all together? Should it be spread out or all in same place?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,994 Posts
If your wife hired me to tie you up in front of the 125, and make you watch me plant a simple scape, much like the rehabilitation scene in Clock Work Orange, this what I would do:

Dwarf Sagittaria - 200

Rosette Sword Plant - 9

Amazon Swords - 3

Red Melon Sword - 12

No LOOK>>> http://www.plantedtank.net/forums/showthread.php?t=200927&page=2 @ post #23.

Take out ALL the rocks on the left and 1 of the 2 in the center. Plant the 3 Amazon Swords in the right rear, in a triangle, 1 in the corner, 1 along the right side, 1 in back next to the corner plant.

Cluster the Rosette Swords in the front middle under the driftwood.

Plant the Red Melons in a Isosceles triangle in the left rear with the longer side of the triangle along the back of the tank.

Fill everything else in the left/center with dwarf sag.

DONE

Once you agreed to leave it alone for 3mos, I'd untie you.

:biggrin:

The less variables, the less can go wrong.

BTW - I would dump in an arm full of Hornwort or Water Lettuce until we got your tank in balance and the plants were thriving, maybe 2-3 wks time.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
679 Posts
I would add a mess of ludwigia repens. Grows great and easy to propagate. Same with rotalla. I noticed your list did not have any stems. I also would agree with the others, limit the plant selection to say...6-7.
 
1 - 20 of 31 Posts
Top