The Planted Tank Forum banner

Is this a baby neocaridina shrimp? Or something else? Planaria maybe?

3.5K views 17 replies 6 participants last post by  Shrimpini  
#1 ·
I have a blue velvet 10 gallon planted tank. I recently added some monte carlo and since then I've had pest snails and white worms on the glass. I thought they might be planaria, so I dosed Panacur, but they are still there.

Now I am also seeing these bigger (maybe 4 mm) grey/white things swimming around quickly. I assumed they are larger planaria, but I managed to catch one and it has legs and antenna, so now I am not sure. Could it be baby shrimp?
 

Attachments

#4 ·
I'd like a bunch of those. Clean-up crew plus great fish treats.
Thanks for the ID! I think ypu are right.

This is a shrimp only tank. Will they hurt the shrimp? I have a couple that are berried, so I don't want to risk taking them out to get rid of the gammarus if i don't have to.

Also are the small white worms on the glass their larvae then and not planaria? Can't get a good picture of those.
 
#6 ·
It’s a daphnia



I recently had the same situation. Uggg. Use planeria zero and that will wipe out the planeria and hydra and other non desirables. I hate buying plants for that reason. If you don’t bleach them first, you will get hit hikers. The thing in the bowl looks like a daphnia to me. I got one of those too. Freaked me out since it did not move like a shrimp. It is a crustacean so planeria zero will not get rid of that. If you don’t like them....I don’t....you need to catch them....sigh

Hope this helps.
 
#10 ·
Possible fishes could include kuhli loaches *or* pygmy cories... might be others. Not guaranteed they *wont* eat shrimp, but many people do keep both species with shrimp and have thriving colonies.


Might be a bit odd but I kind of think gammarus are cute! lol They're like underwater roly polies! Never dealt with them myself though... but I've seen them!
 
#14 ·
Yes, I don't mind their looks so much, as I can barely make out the features. I just want my shrimp and potential baby shrimp to be safe! I've been just catching the big ones put whenever possible, until I can decide what to do about them. I'm setting up another 10 gallon, so I will hold off on fish until that is ready for them long term.

Regarding the white worms, I used panacur, but they did not go away, so at this point I think they are detritus worms. As far as I know, they don't harm shrimp.

Sidenote: This was my first post on the forum and everyone's help has been MUCH appreciated!
 
#12 ·
Creatures

Since setting up my tank....about 6 weeks....and adding plants......various creatures have popped up. Is this normal? Or is it just an unfortunate reality that comes with live plants? And for shrimp breeding in particular......how do you keep detritus worms under control without starving your tank? It seems that powdered foods are best for new shrimplettes but I feel like providing food and handling worms are a battle.
 
#13 ·
Yes, it's normal. It's part of having a healthy (as healthy as humans can maintain) ecosystem in a glass box.

Detritus worms, daphnia explosions and all that are generally only going to be around in large numbers when your tank is young. Give it a couple months and their populations will balance out or disappear all together.

If you have a well-established tank (say, 6 months+)? Baby and juvenile shrimp will have all the food they need to survive. Shrimplet-specific foods are really only something to use if you know you need them or when you've been shrimping long enough to try something new. And even then, you're feeding such tiny amounts that foods usually don't create any issues.

Since setting up my tank....about 6 weeks....and adding plants......various creatures have popped up. Is this normal? Or is it just an unfortunate reality that comes with live plants? And for shrimp breeding in particular......how do you keep detritus worms under control without starving your tank? It seems that powdered foods are best for new shrimplettes but I feel like providing food and handling worms are a battle.
 
#15 ·
I guess a good question might be... are the worms kind of short and fat/flat? And really small?

Or long and slender? And kind of... well... long?


Short, fat/flat and small points to rhabdocoela flatworms. Not always harmed by treatment to get rid of planaria.

Long, slender, and... once again, long... that could be detritus (swims like a snake if in water column), nematodes (squiggles...) or possibly some other worm.