The Planted Tank Forum banner

1 - 20 of 54 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
123 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I have been asking questions for a couple of weeks around here, and am very grateful for the answers so far received. I decided to jump in, and start a tank journal.

DISCLAIMER: This is my first try. Mistakes will doubtless be made (I've made a few already!)...Feel free to advise, but please don't be offended if I take a wrong turn.

What I got: A 37 gallon tall, with wood stand. It was given to me with a non-working Aqueon 50, some gravel, and some other junk.

What I've bought, so far:

Two 20lb bags of EcoComplete. Trying to support the LFS, since I know the kid, and he's new in business. $60. YES, I have learned my lesson.
A honking big chunk of driftwood from a garden center, that I have already cut into two pieces. $25
A bag of Scott's topsoil at Walmart $5
A Bag of play sand $4
A bag of red lava landscape rock $5
A clamp on shop light fixture $7, and a HUGE cfl bulb $8. (had NO idea how big this bulb was when I bought it...It is a temp, so I have light to work. A more decorative light plan is in the works.


A few pics:



The tank, as received, with two pieces of driftwood (testing for fit)



The driftwood piece I will be using. It was a saltwater piece...There are remains of small oysters on it. However, it was harvested over five years ago from brackish/fresh water, in the Withlacoochee River, and has been weathering outdoors in a garden center ever since. I then soaked and rinsed it in dechlorinated water for a week.



I made 'sausages' to bank the back of the tank. I took rinsed red lava rock, and packed it into old knee high nylon stockings, which I then tied off and trimmed. Next pic shows how I used them:



The four lava sausages long the back edge of the aquarium. I filled in any space around them, and about an inch over the rest of the tank bottom with play sand.



Driftwood placed on top of the lava. This was tricky: I was not confident that the wood would stay down. So, I used fishing line to attach a lava bag to the driftwood...However, I had to fill the sand in around the driftwood, since I couldn't think of a better way.



So...This could have gone better. I decided not to rinse the topsoil. I KNOW. Had no good way to dry it out after rinsing, no real good way to rinse and strain it. I had read some people had good success with this soil, by basically just chucking it in, and straining wood matter off the top. Sooo, I did that. It was HORRIFYING :icon_mrgr

Two problems: 1)As I added water, the sand and topsoil ran down hill, so the bottom of the tank is now pretty level (so much for my elevation changes).
2) The gift Aqueon does not work, correctly. It only works intermittently, and not at all with the long pick up tube shown. I had intended to let it run to clarify the water, but cannot do that, now. I also can't buy a pump for another ten days.

I am going to try to rescape the soil once the tank is in place...But I know it is going to turn back into chocolate soup.

That's okay...In the pic, the soil had only been settling for a few hours. It is looking clearer, today. But there is more to do:

Tomorrow, the wall where the tank will be is being painted. I do not want to add any more weight to it before that. So, once in place, I plan to try and 're-scape' the soil levels...THEN add the Eco Complete.

Lessons learned:

Maybe I should have rinsed the dirt
PRETEST THE EQUIPMENT BEFORE YOU NEED IT
Learn more about elevations in substrate

I expect no further updates before the weekend. I am pretty humble, so don't be afraid to say so if you see me driving off a cliff.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
700 Posts
another thing that might have happened is that you started running the filter before the big heavy bits in the water from your substrate settled down. If you didn't wait and didn't have a prefilter sponge on your intake tube, odds are some big rock chunks of gravel made it up your tube, blocked your filter's impeller, and maybe even burnt out the motor. don't ask me how I know that this is a possibility, haha.

for now, take the filter apart and check the impeller. if you have a bunch of gravel in there with the impeller, there's your answer. clean that out and try running it in a bucket of clean tap water to see if the filter's ok. if so, stick a sponge on the end of that intake tube for now before sticking it back in the tank.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
123 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·
Thanks, Jahn. In fact, I did exactly that, today...Ran it in clean water on a five gallon bucket. The impeller was clear, and in fact ran fine. It just would not take up water, sometimes. Especially not through the long tube. I tried priming it, and even starting it with the clear tube filled with water. It would sometimes pump long enough to fill the filter reservoir, but then quit, with motor still running. I am just going to have to get another...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
123 Posts
Discussion Starter · #4 ·
Mini-Update: Hey! I can actually SEE through the tank, front to back, today. I am a little more confident that once I cover the top soil with the Eco Complete, it will settle down. Moving the tank to the permanent location should happen tonight or tomorrow, and I will post pics once I have the Eco Complete in.

I also now have a list of plants, and later fish...Will try to post those up for input later tonight.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
226 Posts
yea i've had similar problems with soil going everywhere, i always make sure to put the sand cap on before addding water it helps to have a plate or something in there to prevent the water from punching right down through the sand and stiring up the dirt. it will eventually settle your wood will be a little crudy from all the sediment but you can just sorta brush it off. it's a nice peice of wood though, it fills the space well.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
123 Posts
Discussion Starter · #6 ·
Progress! Son of a friend has taken an interest in my tank, stopped by tonight with an Aqua Tech 30-60 filter that he is not using, anymore. Did not take any money for it.

It is actually MUCH larger than the non working Aqueon. Too late to mess with it, tonight. I was going to try a little sand over the topsoil, and the Eco Complete, before work tomorrow. But I don't want to start the filter untested while I will be away from home.

SEE??! I AM learning!

I said I wasn't going to rush things...This is a test.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
301 Posts
Seems like a good start so far. My 10g is dirted with miracle grow organic potting mix.

I started by soaking the soil in a 5g bucket with de chlorinated water and removed the larger wood chunks with my hand. If you stir the dirt a bit the wood will float and the soil will sink to the bottom and form a pretty soft mud that you can scoop out and apply directly to your tank.

First time I tried I had waaaaaay too much dirt and too much cap. All together it was probably around 4inches of substrate. I ended up removing it all and using about 1.5inch of dirt and 1.5inch of gravel cap. Its better to get things right for the longrun before you have plants grown in everywhere :O. In reality anything is fine as long as you are satisfied with how it looks.

Looks like you started well with soil that looks ok(looked it up on google) and eco complete. I'd probably cap with eco complete if I did another dirted tank because gravel is a bit harder to plant in.

As a guess to the filter.. When you were doing the tests in the 5g bucket was the water level up to the top of the bucket and the filter hanging directly on the rim? Basically the part where the water comes out should be at the height of the water level. Then fill the filter completely with water and fill the clear tube part.

Could be the motor is dying or could be clogged. On most of the hang on the back type filters you can actually remove the impeller completely and check if there is dirt etc on it and just wipe that off. I have this issue with one of my filters and after a couple months the filter will sometimes make a stuttering noise and continues.

Sounds like it could just be an old filter that doesn't work though, just running through the checklist :p.

After a couple large water changes the tank will clear up but will leak tannins from the peat for quite some time. The water turns a bit brownish but its ok its beneficial.

+1 to prefilter on your filter. If you don't want to buy a sponge type(they only run about $2.99) you can use stockings as long as they don't have any chemicals on them. I do recommend the sponge prefilter though because it will sift out some of the dirt particles before they make it into your filter(saves you some effort when cleaning).

Good luck :)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
123 Posts
Discussion Starter · #8 ·
Okay, I didn't make it to the weekend...HAD to get my arms wet.

The water had settled, a bit, without any filtration. I sat and stared at the tank for half an hour, really loathe to stir it up, again. I decided to try and cap with sprinkled sand, and then the Eco Complete. My thinking was that the sand might keep it from silting up when I put in the Eco.

Of course, I made a hash of it, hehehe!

I poured the Eco Complete direct from the bags, and punched a few holes through sand...Stirring up the silt. Then, the GIFT pump didn't work, after water fill. Got a replacement, because my girl is awesome, and hates to see me sad. (Also, I think she wanted the 'mud puddle' phase over as quickly as possible.

The filter is an Aqua Tech 30-50, same as the one that was given to me. It has been running for about an hour, and water is somewhat clearer. It generates a LOT of water movement!

A few pics follow...


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Front shot...You can see my attempted sand cap, the thin white line. You can also see that it did not do what I hoped.



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

End view, showing substrate layering



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Front view, after 45 minutes of filtration...LOOK! You can SEE the driftwood! Sort of.



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

End view, and I can now see THREE WHOLE inches into the tank!



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

I bought one of those cheap bulb packages at WalMart...These are Hardy Aponogeton. Three of the four have come up already.



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Front of the glass, because it has my family name, AND it is World Cup related!

 

·
Registered
Joined
·
123 Posts
Discussion Starter · #9 ·
Much better this morning! I can at least see WHY it was so murky: A few sport where the topsoil is still 'sticking out' through the sand and Eco Complete. Will fix after work, this evening.

 

·
Registered
Joined
·
700 Posts
personally I wouldn't have put a filter in that tank until the substrate settled out of the water. as said above, by using the filter to clear the water, what you're doing is basically sucking up substrate en masse into your impeller. if you water is "dusty," it means you probably didn't rinse your substrate before putting it into the tank - don't use your filter as the rinser. it also looks like you didn't put a prefilter over your intake tube as suggested - odds are that bits bigger than just dust made its way up the tube and gunked up your filter.

take your new filter apart and check the impeller. really rinse out everything that's there. it only takes a little grime to gunk up the mechanism and make your filter stutter or run slower, or even so slow that it doesn't suck water up the tube anymore.

---

you also have to think about how deep you're making that substrate. if you make it too deep, there is a good chance that some nasty pockets of anaerobic toxic gas are going to eventually build up in there, and not be able to escape from the substrate until one day it all rushes out, gasses your tank, and kills your fish. 1-2 inches? sure. 4-5 inches? problem. if you keep it that deep, make certain you get plants that reach all the way down there with a strong root structure, and/or get a bunch of burrowing fauna like malaysian trumpet snails. otherwise, just never disturb the substrate in fear that a pocket lurks...

--

in the future if you ever do want to add even more substrate (not recommended), you can rise a cup of say eco-complete, then add that wet substrate by lowering it in a cup down to the existing substrate and gently pouring it out right on the substrate. that way you don't scatter it all over the water column. other people have tried funnelling it down a tube, but i find the cup approach to be more controllable.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
123 Posts
Discussion Starter · #11 ·
Thanks, Jahn. I realized last night that I had WAY too much substrate. Unwilling to start over from scratch, so I am just going to have to be extra vigilant. You are correct, I did not pre-rinse the substrate soil...Had no good way to wet it, spread it, etc.

Will take the filter down this afternoon, and give it a good going over. A very few bits of woody material were, indeed, on the intake screen this morning.

I also meant to add, above: I am THRILLED with the driftwood...It really has a great 'presence' in the tank, there are spaces under it, that make little caves and passages, and it STAYED DOWN! I was a little worried that it would, well...Drift.

Question: Are Anaerobic pockets a problem in non-fertilized top soil? For some reason, I thought that was only a problem using the potting soils that had ferts in them...Though, I am probably wrong. Will follow your advice about deep planting and trumpet snails.
 

·
Carpe Diem
Joined
·
7,563 Posts
A bit too late of a comment, but that's a lot of substrate: volume and types... Planting and replanting will be tricky, you might want to invest ~$10 into long stainless steel tweezers.
The driftwood is a real gem, even much so for the price.

Love your humor an attitude: see you at the bottom of that cliff :)

via Droid DNA Tapatalk 2
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
123 Posts
Discussion Starter · #13 ·
Thanks OVT...As I said, first attempt. Bound to be mistakes.

In a way, I kind of wish the girlfriend (Anita) hadn't been excited to have it in the living room. I would feel better making mistakes in the dank confines of my den. There is a bit of pressure to get past the "Glass cube of muddy hell" phase in the living room.

Next time around:

1) Less substrate, probably potting soil and sand
2) Better lighting plan
3) Cannister filtration instead of HOB
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
123 Posts
Discussion Starter · #15 ·
Update

Took Jahn's advice, came home, took filter off and cleaned it. Not much wood, but the blue filters were verrry dusty. Put it back together, and now, it looks like this:

 

·
Registered
Joined
·
123 Posts
Discussion Starter · #16 ·
Late tonight...

MUCH happier with how things look, tonight:

For comparison, one of the shots I took immediately after filling the tank, and one I took tonight of the same end...




~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Full tank shot, front:



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Closer up of the driftwood:



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Other end of the tank:



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Now time to consider plants...Hope to be able to buy some Thursday. My working list:

Java Moss
Java Fern
Anubias
Cryptocyrene usteriana
Amazon Sword
Nymphoides aquatica (banana plant)
Vallisnaria nana
Dwarf Bonsai
Brazilian pennywort

Fish list...This decision still a ways away:

Cory cats
Guppies
Congo Tetra
Thai micro crabs
Featherfin Rainbow
Freshwater puffer
(burrowing snails were suggested, upthread, for substrate health, since I put too much in)

These lists are nowhere NEAR finalized...Just things I like the look of, that seem to me low-med light plants, and easy to medium plants. On the fish, just things that SEEM fairly okay in a community tank...Still need a lot more input on my fauna choices.

Your ideas welcome...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
123 Posts
Discussion Starter · #17 ·
Simple solutions, and a gift...

Couple of things:

1) From the DON'T OVERTHINK IT Department- I have those bulbs in a glass, and they have all sprouted. I want them in the tank water, but was worried about them moving around in the water flow...So I was trying to come up with a way to hang a basket on the edge, etc. It suddenly hit me, the simplest possible solution:



2) Had a private message from a TPT member about my plant list...He has very graciously offered a BUNCH of good plants, if I can be patient and wait a few weeks. I can, but am going to go ahead and get some java moss started, because I want to get it established on the driftwood as soon as possible.

So, thanks, dtejeda.arias...I anxiously await your RAOK!:icon_lol:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
123 Posts
Discussion Starter · #18 ·
Just took my first set of water readings...YEESH!

API 5 in 1 kit showed:

General Hardness: 180
Carbonate Hardness: 120
PH: 9.0 (!)
NO2: .5
NO3: 0

I know those numbers are not good...Am going to ask some questions in the 'Tank Parameters' section. My first guess is the driftwood, which was originally in salt water, but has been 'leeching and bleaching' at a garden shop for four years.

When I filled it from our tap water, I DID use the API water conditioner when I filled the tank...Would that affect my readings?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
754 Posts
Your puffer will love the micro crabs, feather fins, and guppies. Might want to reconsider that sp. they are awesome in a sp. tank only
 
1 - 20 of 54 Posts
Top