The Planted Tank Forum banner

Filter recommendation

1415 Views 15 Replies 7 Participants Last post by  Curt_914
I recently replaced my Rena xp2 with a fluval fx5. Now I can't run my inline heater or my reactor.
I'm looking for a cheap canister with 5/8 tubing that I can run alongside my fx5 so I don't have to use this stupid in tank heater and ceramic diffuser

I don't want to spend more than 100 bucks it has to have 5/8 tubing.

I will probably run this filter empty for more flow/ less maintenance.

I'm also pondering the idea of some how turning this filter into a reactor.has anyone done this or have any ideas on how to make it work?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
1 - 16 of 16 Posts
I have not done this! But I daydreamed about it. I was thinking that on a fluval 105 I could remove the suction cup primer on the inlet pull the rubber rod out and fish some 1/4 inch tubing through the rods hole. Could put a airstone type diffuser there or leave the line hanging low. Glue or tap an 1-1/4 or 1" PVC over the opening on the clip on impeller cover. Cut it so it lands about 1/2" abouve the canister sump bottom. The inlet and housing are curved already so bubbles want to head up it instead of the impeller on the outlet. This would be kinda like a motorized cerges reactor using counter flow. But should be named a Foley reactor!:)

Have you thought about putting a 5/8 bypass line on your fx5? It would save electricity and cost of a new pump. A bypass doesn't take from flow rate.... Or just a tee 1" x 5/8" tee use your 5/8 equipment and terminate in tank with a different end... Say a small sprayer? And leave you fx5 dual outlet alone. The fx5 builds quite a bit of pressure in the out hose a 5/8 tee may increase the over all flow rate of the pump by allowing the energy as volume instead of pressure. The outlet would effectively be a 1-5/8 line.
See less See more
I will probably run this filter empty for more flow/ less maintenance.

I personally would make it a mechanical only filter. In order to keep the UV tubes internals clean, you should clean the water of particulates first.
You can put a polishing pad in here.... Many ppl buy http://portland.craigslist.org/wsc/for/3270750365.html just to move from tank to tank polishing
http://portland.craigslist.org/mlt/for/3267377211.html
Be the first try it! 60 bucks and if it don't work..... Well put the primer back it , clean the glue up and use as normal.
Out of curiosity why can't you run inline items with an FX5?
Fx5 have a 1"id piping. His equiptment is 5/8.
Fx5 have a 1"id piping. His equiptment is 5/8.
Can't you just buy some PVC and convert the 5/8 to 1" or vice versa?
Can't you just buy some PVC and convert the 5/8 to 1" or vice versa?
It will cause a reduction in flow. I could run a "Y" but the fx5 is so sensitive to air leaks causing micro bubbles that I would rather just leave it alone and run all my equipment on a smaller canister


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I have not done this! But I daydreamed about it. I was thinking that on a fluval 105 I could remove the suction cup primer on the inlet pull the rubber rod out and fish some 1/4 inch tubing through the rods hole. Could put a airstone type diffuser there or leave the line hanging low. Glue or tap an 1-1/4 or 1" PVC over the opening on the clip on impeller cover. Cut it so it lands about 1/2" abouve the canister sump bottom. The inlet and housing are curved already so bubbles want to head up it instead of the impeller on the outlet. This would be kinda like a motorized cerges reactor using counter flow. But should be named a Foley reactor!:)

Have you thought about putting a 5/8 bypass line on your fx5? It would save electricity and cost of a new pump. A bypass doesn't take from flow rate.... Or just a tee 1" x 5/8" tee use your 5/8 equipment and terminate in tank with a different end... Say a small sprayer? And leave you fx5 dual outlet alone. The fx5 builds quite a bit of pressure in the out hose a 5/8 tee may increase the over all flow rate of the pump by allowing the energy as volume instead of pressure. The outlet would effectively be a 1-5/8 line.
This is sort of what I'm thinking I have not thought this far into it yet but I think it would be a lot easier to plan once I have a filter to use


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I was looking at the 304 with the built in uv sterilizer.....the price seems to good to be true. What's the quality like on these


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I cant say anything about the quality of the 304 never owned one myself.

I'd just run the XP2 you replaced to hook all your in-line items up. I would use mechanical media in the XP2 and fill the FX5 with bio. Or leave the FX5 as is and run the XP2 with minimal media if any at all...
They are ok, no Ehiem of FX5 but I have 4 and they have been running for 2 years now, I use them all with media, 2 with CO2 reactors in line..... I like them for a cheap canister
I cant say anything about the quality of the 304 never owned one myself.

I'd just run the XP2 you replaced to hook all your in-line items up. I would use mechanical media in the XP2 and fill the FX5 with bio. Or leave the FX5 as is and run the XP2 with minimal media if any at all...
The xp2 is on a new tank I just set up


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Just run an inline pump like a Mag drive 3 or 5. Thats what I do and you get a beter flow rate. you have an FX5 why put another canister on the tank if its not really needed.

Curt
1 - 16 of 16 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top