The Planted Tank Forum banner
1 - 20 of 20 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
167 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I live in the high desert and temperatures reach up into the 110's at times during the summer/fall. I've seen the tank get up to 86 degrees. With a newly set up planted tank there's no way I'm taking the risk of just seeing how it plays out this summer.

I'll be making my own digital temp controller using the stc-1000. I have all the parts on order. I'm searching far and wide for info on specific fans that hobbyists are using for evaporative cooling and coming up empty.

I've ran through a few options without pulling the trigger. My biggest concern is what size fan to get, to cool my 72 gallon bowfront effecitvely. I like the idea of using a regular office type clip on fan, just not sure if that will work best. I also like the idea of using pc cooling fans but trying to figure out how much cfm I need is stumping me.

So any suggestions on a fan set up would be appreciated.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,653 Posts
I have the same controller. My plan is a computer fan array mounted on a wood platform, hanging on the tank, that will blow across the length of the tank. I am using this on a 75 to begin with and will probably use 4 fans 110v 120x38mm. I will plug the fans into a surge protector that is itself plugged into a receptacle connected to the cool side of the controller.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
167 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·
I have the same controller. My plan is a computer fan array mounted on a wood platform, hanging on the tank, that will blow across the length of the tank. I am using this on a 75 to begin with and will probably use 4 fans 110v 120x38mm. I will plug the fans into a surge protector that is itself plugged into a receptacle connected to the cool side of the controller.
Good idea on the surge protector. The other thing is my tank is open top. I did research enough to see alot of people complaining that the pc type fans just don't move much air in that set up. I think with a canopy they are much more effective.

Let me know how it goes. If you get the fans on there and they're moving a good amount of air that may be the route I take.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,653 Posts
Its going to be a bit. I wont even need them for 3 or 4 months, we just had a blizzard go through. I wouldn't think it would take much. I dont expect to cool the tank a whole lot. The fans I am looking at are high speed models and will probably produce some noise. They also make a speed controller for them as well.

You have another option as well if I may suggest it. Use the cool side of the controller to run a pump and pump the water through cooling pipes arranged in coils in a mini fridge, in essence a home made chiller. They actually make small ones for truckers that are actually 12 volt that you could connect to an ac/dc power supply. Wouldnt cost much to do. The home beer brewing industry is a good place to look if you are interested in that type of setup. Of course that will take more room than a fan but will be much more effective and will cool more efficiently and quietly. Ive thought about this option as well. A small cooler would fit well underneath my tank cabinet.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
167 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
You have another option as well if I may suggest it. Use the cool side of the controller to run a pump and pump the water through cooling pipes arranged in coils in a mini fridge, in essence a home made chiller. They actually make small ones for truckers that are actually 12 volt that you could connect to an ac/dc power supply. Wouldnt cost much to do. The home beer brewing industry is a good place to look if you are interested in that type of setup. Of course that will take more room than a fan but will be much more effective and will cool more efficiently and quietly. Ive thought about this option as well. A small cooler would fit well underneath my tank cabinet.
Wow, you just sent me on a 20 minute meditation trip with that one. I spent that time planning the whole thing out logistically. Lol I know a bit of HVAC and refrigeration. This sounds like a fun option. I'll give it some more thought. It just much more involved than clipping on a fan or two.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,653 Posts
Definitely more involved but for the type of heat you have it would work better and keep your temps more consistent than fans would it seems to me. I'm going to subscribe to this thread, I hope you will let us know what you do and how it works out.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
167 Posts
Discussion Starter · #7 ·
For sure, I'll update it as I go with this project. If I can keep the tank steady at anywhere from 80 to 82 then I'd call it a win. I have fish and plants that should be able to tolerate that temp range.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
36 Posts
Hey I had the same type of problem on a Reef setup I had. Basically it was on the top floor of my house and it was a HQI bulb. I didn't want to invest in a chiller so I bought a fan that had a thermistor built into it and set it up to blow across the water especially hitting the location of the overflow and high surface agitation areas to best cool the water.

There is a brand called IceCap that makes these fans and they are ready to go no DIY needed and they work great. For my tank I had the themp probe resting right on the canopy so as the lights went on and the heat went up the fan ramped up accordingly. Being that the water level was right below that the probe could sense the temp rising off the water and would ramp up if the temp got too bad even with the lights off.

I see marinedepot has them for $35. I think I may have gotten mine off of ebay for like $20 brand new.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
167 Posts
Discussion Starter · #9 ·
Appreciate the info. I ended up going with an STC 1000 controller and a fan. I can plug my heater into the control box as well. It ended up being alot more money than what that Ice Cap fan costs. At least I got to build and use my tools though, that's priceless.

I'll post a picture of the set up when I have it up and running. It's ready now, just not warm enough to use it yet.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,653 Posts
@SNAXX Would you say it cost more considering you got heat and cooling control? If you could to do it over would you do it different?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
167 Posts
Discussion Starter · #11 ·
If I could do it over I would have not bought the $20 mounting arm or the $20 fan off Amazon. It was an impulse buy and took the total past $60. It looks great though. It's a clamp on camera/whatever mount and the fan pushes good cfm. I think a simple clip on fan would have sufficed.

As far as the controller I have no complaints. It was easy to gather the parts and build. I'll need to buy another project box as I ended up mauling the controller cut out before I realized all I had to do was turn the Dremel up to speed. No biggie though. The alternative is a $200 or more chiller or a mini fridge set up that I researched and seemed like it just wouldn't help with a 72 gallon tank.
 

Attachments

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,653 Posts
I still have to setup the cooling side on two of my tanks. I'm curious to see how well this works for you as far as temperature drops you see with it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
12,428 Posts
I like to keep it as simple as possible and things like cooling that I don't use too often get very little. I find just moving the humid air out so less humid air moves in over the water is all I need for evaporative cooling to get what I need. That lets me use computer fans. They are like $4-5 dollars new from Fry's or better is used salvage from old computers. I like to find 12VDC fans so that I can use power supplies from salvage. Most any power supply will run one or more fans so it leaves the wiring very simple as I tie them into the controllers I use.
For mounting? I go simple and use plexiglass. Cut the piece, cut a hole for the air and bolt it on.


The odd shape is due to me using it as a camping fan also. It fits the shape of my car window! That's why it has a bug screen?
For tank use, I just lay it flat or prop it. At 12VDC, I don't worry much if it should ever slip in. One reason I like 12VDC is that I always have to plan for accidents. Another reason to like the computer fan is the noise. They are as quiet as possible and I can still add more fans if I did need them. I can't see beating the price.

 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,653 Posts
@PlantedRich Simple and effective. These could easily be controlled with those controller boxes as well and kicked on and off as needed. Good stuff with no difficult mounting. I like it.
Edit: Oh and low cost as well which is always a plus in my book.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
167 Posts
Discussion Starter · #16 ·
I like to keep it as simple as possible and things like cooling that I don't use too often get very little. I find just moving the humid air out so less humid air moves in over the water is all I need for evaporative cooling to get what I need. That lets me use computer fans. They are like $4-5 dollars new from Fry's or better is used salvage from old computers. I like to find 12VDC fans so that I can use power supplies from salvage. Most any power supply will run one or more fans so it leaves the wiring very simple as I tie them into the controllers I use.
For mounting? I go simple and use plexiglass. Cut the piece, cut a hole for the air and bolt it on.


The odd shape is due to me using it as a camping fan also. It fits the shape of my car window! That's why it has a bug screen?
For tank use, I just lay it flat or prop it. At 12VDC, I don't worry much if it should ever slip in. One reason I like 12VDC is that I always have to plan for accidents. Another reason to like the computer fan is the noise. They are as quiet as possible and I can still add more fans if I did need them. I can't see beating the price.

Great ideas. Where were you when I started this thread?!? Lol. I may do this for my 10 gallon housing my pair of CPO crays. I don't think there will be a need for temp control as the 10 gallon is in the hottest part of the house.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
12,428 Posts
While I like to get things for free from junk computers, there are times that spending $5 can be the better choice than driving ten miles to get one free! I am lucky to have a Fry's store on a route I take so I have bought a few things there. Shopping and the pursuit of the "bargain" is part of the fun for some of us.
This is one that I like for the ease of wiring it to the power supply. It comes with several wires and plugs that I don't need and cut off all but the two that go to the fan itself before plugging it into the controller. Whether the controller is needed or not will depend on the size of the tank and how long you might need the cooling.

FRYS.com[censored]|[censored]Raidmax

Part of my thinking on choosing the fans is that it doesn't need to move a huge mass of air very quickly. Humid air moved out will be replaced by drier air and then that dry air needs to have some time to "soak up" moisture from the water surface. So as long as air is moving, water will evaporate and cool the tank. This little fan is rated for 45 cubic feet per minute and that's not much for fans but it is a whole bunch of air moved across a tank when you think about it. If you think of at four foot tank that is 18" front to back, that is six square feet. If we moved air one inch deep uniformly all across that six square feet, we are changing out the air six times a minute---unless I dropped some math somewhere.
I'm certain that I don't get near total movement but it is plenty for what I've needed.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
12,428 Posts
I also had major questions on how much flow was needed. But that is often secondary when I'm building from seat of the pants and using scrap/salvaged stuff like fans and power supplies. I figured the worst if it was too small was adding a second fan or more until it worked. I really love my quiet and computers are that.
What I find is that the best info I can read will often come up short so I just go with what's on hand and adjust as needed.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,653 Posts
1 - 20 of 20 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top