Joined
·
12,433 Posts
There is a really large amount of bogus information passed around so we have to do some real filtering.
Strain on motors is often mentioned but that is old thinking. As I understand "strain", it would mean the motor was called on to do more than designed. So if you have a traditional motor, it has several things that the mag drive motors we use don't have. Take a sump pump as an example. It has a fixed impeller on a shaft, connected to a large moving part made up of metal wires wrapped on a core. These windings are fed current through a set of brushes and do carry electrical power. This is a standard type motor.
When you overload and slow down this motor, the cooling is reduced. A funny electrical thing happens as wires warm. They begin to carry more current. More current produces more heating. You've got a basic death spiral and the motor burns out when the wire insulation melts.
A mag drive has no brushes and no wires on the moving part connected to the impeller. So if you overload or even stop the impeller, there is no major increase in heat, no increase in current and no death spiral. There is a slight increase in heat due to the water flow stopping but as long as the motor is setting in water, that heat can't get very hot until all the water is turned to steam and gassed off. Not really even a thought when you just cut the flow through a canister filter.
If your water going through the filter gets up over two hundred degrees so that it steams, you do have problems but the filter will be one of the smaller things to worry about!
Reason for turning down the output is that turning down the input may make the impeller cavitate and that makes noise.
Strain on motors is often mentioned but that is old thinking. As I understand "strain", it would mean the motor was called on to do more than designed. So if you have a traditional motor, it has several things that the mag drive motors we use don't have. Take a sump pump as an example. It has a fixed impeller on a shaft, connected to a large moving part made up of metal wires wrapped on a core. These windings are fed current through a set of brushes and do carry electrical power. This is a standard type motor.
When you overload and slow down this motor, the cooling is reduced. A funny electrical thing happens as wires warm. They begin to carry more current. More current produces more heating. You've got a basic death spiral and the motor burns out when the wire insulation melts.
A mag drive has no brushes and no wires on the moving part connected to the impeller. So if you overload or even stop the impeller, there is no major increase in heat, no increase in current and no death spiral. There is a slight increase in heat due to the water flow stopping but as long as the motor is setting in water, that heat can't get very hot until all the water is turned to steam and gassed off. Not really even a thought when you just cut the flow through a canister filter.
If your water going through the filter gets up over two hundred degrees so that it steams, you do have problems but the filter will be one of the smaller things to worry about!
Reason for turning down the output is that turning down the input may make the impeller cavitate and that makes noise.