The Planted Tank Forum banner
Cancel

Eco complete or Stratum ?

7137 Views 10 Replies 7 Participants Last post by  jtammerman, 
S
Eco complete or Stratum for a planted tank?

What do you think is better or worth the price?


Thanks.
Reply
Save
Like
1 - 11 of 11 Posts
F
Hi!
I use Stratum, because it is made from volcanic soil that provides pH-balanced environment.
Reply
Save
Like
evil8
I've used both. Eco Complete is inert whereas Stratum isn't. It just soaks up ferts to release slowly. Stratum seems to hold stems better on initial planting (though it's still a pain in the ass) and I've seem to get a little better root growth at the onset in the newer tank I set up a few months ago. That could be my imagination too. LOL...
Reply
Save
Like
miataisalwaystheanswer
Stratum is light and can be difficult to plant in. It will also break down over time. Eco complete is heavier and will not break down. If you don't need to keep PH low I'd go with eco complete. But if you need a lower PH for shrimps or plants I'd go for stratum. I've used both but my overall favorite for buffering substrate is Brightwell
Reply
Save
Like
somewhatshocked
Are those the only two options? If so, is it because you're restricted to a particular retailer?

If not, Flourite (comes in a few different colors) is a much better - and usually cheaper - inert substrate option than Eco-Complete.

If you need an active substrate for some reason, there are much better options than Fluval Stratum at the same or similar price points.
Reply
Save
Like
  • Like
Reactions: 1
J
I strongly advise people to avoid eco-complete. It is too coarse for most fishes I keep but perhaps you are keeping an oscar or something.... certainly most cory and cichlid would prefer something finer. Can't comment on stratum never used it.
Reply
Save
Like
S
jake21 said:
I strongly advise people to avoid eco-complete. It is too coarse for most fishes I keep but perhaps you are keeping an oscar or something.... certainly most cory and cichlid would prefer something finer. Can't comment on stratum never used it.
Click to expand...
What substrate are you using? Does the lava rock hold in nutriments better than just normal gravel? Is their appeal that its porous so the roots have something to go into better than gravel?

My issue with Eco-complete black lava rock one is that they get sucked up in the siphon during water changes and stops the flow of water.

somewhatshocked said:
Are those the only two options? If so, is it because you're restricted to a particular retailer?

If not, Flourite (comes in a few different colors) is a much better - and usually cheaper - inert substrate option than Eco-Complete.

If you need an active substrate for some reason, there are much better options than Fluval Stratum at the same or similar price points.
Click to expand...
I am limited to my local Petco's selection. Maybe Petsupermarket might also be an option if I drive further.

miataisalwaystheanswer said:
Stratum is light and can be difficult to plant in. It will also break down over time. Eco complete is heavier and will not break down. If you don't need to keep PH low I'd go with eco complete. But if you need a lower PH for shrimps or plants I'd go for stratum. I've used both but my overall favorite for buffering substrate is Brightwell
Click to expand...
It will break down? I thought they were some sort of rock structure? What to they break down to and do the planted like/grow in the broken down material?

Are you saying you have to constantly add more of it just to keep even?

Thanks.
See less See more
Reply
Save
Like
somewhatshocked
sirnukesalot007 said:
It will break down? I thought they were some sort of rock structure? What to they break down to and do the planted like/grow in the broken down material?

Are you saying you have to constantly add more of it just to keep even?

Thanks.
Click to expand...
Fluval Stratum is a clay & soil-based substrate that will eventually break down over time. If you don't disturb it, it won't break down quickly. But as a first substrate, it's probably not the best option. It also alters your water parameters in a manner than can be drastic - depending upon circumstances.

If you want a dark substrate, look for regular Petco black sand. Usually comes in 20lb bags and is usually $10-$20. I think it's a much better option than Fluval Stratum or Eco-Complete. If you don't care about color or just want something that appears more natural, Caribsea Peace River is really fine/small gravel that's sometimes available at pet stores. There's also pool filter sand from your local hardware store. Usually $5-8ish for 50lbs.

Flourite is also clay-based but it's fired and doesn't really break down. Easy to plant in. Comes in a "sand" option that is really just ground up and fired Flourite and Flourite fines.
Reply
Save
Like
J
sirnukesalot007 said:
What substrate are you using? Does the lava rock hold in nutriments better than just normal gravel? Is their appeal that its porous so the roots have something to go into better than gravel?

My issue with Eco-complete black lava rock one is that they get sucked up in the siphon during water changes and stops the flow of water.
Click to expand...
I doubt it. I have one tank with it but it isn't fair to compare since i've added co2 injection to that tank. Here is a tank without it (low tech):
Plant Pet supply Terrestrial plant Aquatic plant Grass

Note there are no difficult to grow plants in this tank but it does fine. In my experience eco-complete does not provide any enhancement of plant growth.

In my experience unless you are growing very delicate plants (in which case you would want a soil like substrate and probably woudln't be asking this sort of question); any inert substrate that 'breathes' (i.e, doesn't form anaerobic pockets) will be equivalent and fine.

The 3 substrates I am using that I like are estes stony river black; carib sea torpedo beach; carb sea crystal river. I used to use carb-sea moonlight but will no longer use it as it seems to quickly form anaerobic pockets.
See less See more
Reply
Save
Like
jtammerman
I actually tried a comparison using three of the substrates mentioned in this post. Fluval Stratum (top left), Eco-Complete (top right), and Seachem Flourite (bottom right). The lighting is the same, but the distances are slightly different, so this isn’t scientific. My observations:
Fluval Stratum
+best root growth
+fastest growth
+easy to plant in
+nice, dark color
+no rinsing needed
-expensive
-does break down (mine seems to get dusty after a few years)
-not as natural looking as Eco-Complete

Eco-Complete
+Most natural looking
+cheapest of the three
+easiest to plant in
+heavy enough to gravel vac without too much trouble
+plant growth was reasonable
+no rinse on setup, no cloudy water
-carpet plants and grasses seem to grow better on Stratum

Seachem Flourite
+Red color looks nice
+Easy to plant in
-messy
-dusty
-seems like you can’t rinse it enough
-dust never seems to go away
-it’s super, super messy
-I hate it
Plant Green Pet supply Aquatic plant Wood
See less See more
Reply
Save
Like
jtammerman
Same tanks after 21 days.
Plant Water Vertebrate Green Botany
See less See more
Reply
Save
Like
1 - 11 of 11 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
The Planted Tank Forum
A forum community dedicated to Aquatic tank owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about flora, fauna, health, housing, filters, care, classifieds, and more!
Full Forum Listing
Explore Our Forums
Tank Journals General Planted Tank Discussion Equipment Fish Shrimp & Other Invertebrates
Top