CaribSea Eco-Complete Planted Aquarium Substrate

im not an expert in anyway... but i used eco complete in my 29gal tank.. i used a 20lb bag... i think the rule is 1lb of gravel per gallon of water. i shouldve used 1.5 bags but i didnt wanna buy a 2nd bag

eco-complete is hard.. its like black gravel. i did research on it long ago, and i forgot most of it, but to me its just black gravel soaked in ferts and nutrients.. (probably isnt)

at first it worked really well, but then i got clado algae from someone's plants.now i have a huge duckweed problem.. and it blocks all the light so my plants melted.

u can always add rootmedic tablets to your tank or dose liquid fertilizers if u wish.

i learned the hard way about mixing substrates and gravel.. its real easy to mix, real hard to separate =x

I also learned the hard way, but I have alot of experience. I used Eco and osmocote and it wasnt enough. Im used to the Mineralized top soil method(although my recipe isnt the same). I highly recommend putting something for root ferts down first. I feel like ive wasted 6 months by not doing something that ive always done.

I have 80lbs in my 55 gallon and I want more depth...

I used 60-80lbs in a 40 breeder. I liked it but was never completely satisfied. I could not get HC or other smaller/finer plants to root.
It's basically black gravel of varying sizes, only it costs more. I like more uniformity or consistency in size.
I'll still use it but i won't ever pay for it again.

Do you have any other substrate or gravel in the same tank or Just Eco-Complete?. Is it soft or Rocky. How long have you had it in tank. What is your openion .

Thanks
Varma

I use 1.5 bags of it in my 10g, the other half went into my 5g. I like it, it is pretty good. Stem plants tend to escape it though, so you need to use strategy. Make sure you don't have trumpet snails or any other snails that dig or else you'll have a hard time with stems.

It is like white gravel with this black porous stuff covering it I think. I had some black pieces that have some white parts exposed. Use some root tabs will be great!

I use it for several months now. It doesn't really afect your water parameters. It doesn't melt away either. Depending on what fish you plan on stocking this may or may not be the substrate of choice for you!

I'm a newbie and thinking about using Eco complete in my 10 gal betta tank. Not sure what plants to use or if I will need any kind of liquid fertilizer.

Varma said:

I am planing to start 55 GAL Fresh water Planted Aquarium and I can really use this community members help in finishing my project.


I am planning to purchase CaribSea Eco-Complete Planted Aquarium Substrate 20 lb bags

1. Please suggest howmuch do I need for my 55 Gal (48x13x21).
2. Do I need any Fertilizer underneeth this Substrate?
3. DO I need to cover this Substrate with any gravel? Do any one know how soft it is? and how it is working out for them when doing gravel cleanups?

Click to expand...

if you can afford Eco, that mean you can spend the same on aquasoil, i had a bad experience with Eco and highly recommend Aqua soil over any other substrate, i use 3-4 bags of Aqua soil in my 50g. if you still want Eco, i have used 5 bags in my 50g, so you get an idea about how much you need.

Eco does not have anything in it, its just high in CEC and you must add root tabs from day one for any benefit. Aqua soil on the other hand is full of fertilizers and high in CEC. it is also peat based soil which will be more beneficial for the plants anyway.

i hope this info helps

What was your bad experience?

carpalstunna said:

What was your bad experience?

Click to expand...

i decided not to discus it, it could change people mind toward Eco.

happi said:

i decided not to discus it, it could change people mind toward Eco.

Click to expand...

Why don't you want to discuss it? If a product worked or didn't work, you should say why so the community can get some insight.

vincenz said:

Why don't you want to discuss it? If a product worked or didn't work, you should say why so the community can get some insight.

Click to expand...

there are mixed answers, you will find some agree with me and some dont.

Read here:
http://www.plantedtank.net/forums/substrate/128069-eco-complete-sucks.html

For reference, I just used 3 bags (total of 60lbs) of Eco-Complete to fill my 40g hexagon long to an average depth of 2.5-3". It's essentially a similar size to the standard 55g but with the front corners cut off. I would suggest at least 4 bags for a 55g, and realistically 5 bags (total 100lbs) would make a nice substrate layer.

I have no issues with vacuuming it (it does not suck up into the hose), and overall I do like it. It is a bit light though, so unless your plants have a good root structure you may have some trouble getting them to stay planted.

Some people suggest a thin layer of peat beneath the Eco-Complete.

I have been using Eco-Complete for years and have never had any problems with growing things with it. As others have stated, sometimes stem plants have trouble staying down, so I started planting more that one in the hole and that seems to work okay. You definitely have to use root tabs for your root feeders. It holds up well though and I would recommend it.

My eco is doing okay, but thanks for the comment on stem plants. I do have a bear of a time getting things to stay in the darn substrate. ><

Eco-Complete as a topping in Walstad Tank

Hello,

I was thinking about using Eco-Complete as the top 1" layer in a new 55 gal Walstad planted tank and was wondering if anyone else had tried this and how well it worked. I'm also going to putting in a bristle nose pleco after it's cycled and roots have established. Will he uproot the plants with this substrate?

Varma said:

I am planing to start 55 GAL Fresh water Planted Aquarium and I can really use this community members help in finishing my project.


I am planning to purchase CaribSea Eco-Complete Planted Aquarium Substrate 20 lb bags

1. Please suggest howmuch do I need for my 55 Gal (48x13x21).
2. Do I need any Fertilizer underneeth this Substrate?
3. DO I need to cover this Substrate with any gravel? Do any one know how soft it is? and how it is working out for them when doing gravel cleanups?

Click to expand...

I just stumbled upon the sticky at the beginning here, and there is a calculator which helps with how much substrate you need.

Hi! I use this substrate, one bag for a 20 gallon high tank and I mean that I don't have any problem. Here I show you a video about this.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mGl_5GK619Y

Hi.
I found that eco complete is high in iron. I measure level of iron in substrate and is about 0.8ppm. More I fertilize water the iron level of substrate increase. Is that because substrate absorb it? When I increase water dosage to 0.07ppm Fe daily after some time Fe in my substrate is over 2ppm. Should I still dose Fe to the water or substrate release Fe into the water?
Thanks
Mario