The Planted Tank Forum banner

1 - 12 of 12 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
595 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 · (Edited)
I am not sure if its because of some kind of protesters but my Home depot has pulled all the miracle grow organic choice(brown bag) and replaced it with " nature's care organic choice)

The primary difference is I think the nature's care organic has poltrey litter( chicken manure I assume) ? Also it said " The moisture holding power of Water Conserve® comes from nature, with cool things like yucca and coir"

Would this be an issue if the planted aquarium has plants only and no fish?

here is a PDF of the packaging for the dirt:

http://www.miraclegro.com/smg/produ...n_container/pdf/mgOrganicChoicePottingMix.pdf

*second page, bottom left are the ingredients.

Thanks.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,261 Posts
I'm reminded of an Uncle who was into organic food. He was on his rant about how good it was for you as he opened a box of organic cereal. Mealy Bugs came flying out of the cereal box and we all started laughing. 'Well', we said, 'it's good for some things!' Sterile, well ground organic matter in soil should be fine. The problem is that soils made for gardening are not going to be of the same industry quality as those made for aquariums. I would not trust it. But if you are willing to give it a go, it will make a great experiment! I've seen a video on youtube where the guy used regular soil out of the ground that he baked in his oven to sterilize. It can be done, but you always run a risk of bacterial growth, fungal growth, and 'mealy bug' growth...hahaha.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
595 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·
I'm reminded of an Uncle who was into organic food. He was on his rant about how good it was for you as he opened a box of organic cereal. Mealy Bugs came flying out of the cereal box and we all started laughing. 'Well', we said, 'it's good for some things!' Sterile, well ground organic matter in soil should be fine. The problem is that soils made for gardening are not going to be of the same industry quality as those made for aquariums. I would not trust it. But if you are willing to give it a go, it will make a great experiment! I've seen a video on youtube where the guy used regular soil out of the ground that he baked in his oven to sterilize. It can be done, but you always run a risk of bacterial growth, fungal growth, and 'mealy bug' growth...hahaha.
What about throwing some bleach in the water, let it sit for a day then empty the water and replace it with freshwater with some prime in it?

Do you think that will kill the baceria and fungas?

Basically, I am trying to grow some drawf baby tears and Monte Carlo and other carpeting plants which have not done that great in my aquarium.

Its kind of a plan B in case the carpeting plant die in my aquarium so I have a backup supply. If I grow enough of it, I might be able to start the carpet process going with more of a supply.

What do you think?

Oven vs Bleach on the dirt?

Thanks.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,653 Posts
I tend to lean towards yard dirt or pure soil with no additives but all I have read says if you follow the normal procedures mineralizing soil you will be fine. The danger you run into with manure is ammonia production at first and mineralizing solves that issue.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,261 Posts
What about throwing some bleach in the water, let it sit for a day then empty the water and replace it with freshwater with some prime in it?

Do you think that will kill the baceria and fungas?

Basically, I am trying to grow some drawf baby tears and Monte Carlo and other carpeting plants which have not done that great in my aquarium.

Its kind of a plan B in case the carpeting plant die in my aquarium so I have a backup supply. If I grow enough of it, I might be able to start the carpet process going with more of a supply.

What do you think?

Oven vs Bleach on the dirt?

Thanks.
I really don't know. I've never heard of people using bleach on soil. You might google those words together and see what you find. I think the video on baking soil is still on youtube. :wink2:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,653 Posts
I wouldnt use bleach or an oven, can you imagine the smell if you put chicken dookie in an oven? Blech. I think simple mineralization should work for you.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
595 Posts
Discussion Starter · #7 ·
I wouldnt use bleach or an oven, can you imagine the smell if you put chicken dookie in an oven? Blech. I think simple mineralization should work for you.
What do you mean by " mineralization "

This will be 100% plant only 0% fish. So its basically more of a wet terrarium than a aquarium.

I don't even know if the plants will be growing in damp soil or submerged under water at this point.
This will only be plants which have the ability to grow in a terrestrial form(outside of water)

I am basically trying to keep a reserve supply of dwarf baby tears and other carpeting plants which I find hard to keep alive in my Aquarium for some reason(probably lack of C02/light/trace minerals?)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
296 Posts
Not going to say it is bad or good, but didn't a guy on this forum do a tank with dog do-do one time? I assume in a quick answer it would probably work, but who knows what kind of things it might do.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,653 Posts
Not going to say it is bad or good, but didn't a guy on this forum do a tank with dog do-do one time? I assume in a quick answer it would probably work, but who knows what kind of things it might do.
I think for what he is doing it will fine as it is right out of the bag.

Yep there has been dog doo tanks as well lol. I think the thread is still around but all of his posts have been deleted or something.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,328 Posts
Should be safe to use. MG Organic Choice potting mix had chicken manure as one of its ingredients. Plus the ammonia from the chicken poop will help cycle the tank.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
595 Posts
Discussion Starter · #12 ·
Not going to say it is bad or good, but didn't a guy on this forum do a tank with dog do-do one time? I assume in a quick answer it would probably work, but who knows what kind of things it might do.
My understanding of organic gardening and composting is that Cow or chicken are ok but dog or cat is bad and should be avoided at all cost.
 
1 - 12 of 12 Posts
Top