The Planted Tank Forum banner
1 - 8 of 8 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,588 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I have been using it for a week now, and I think my shrimps are dying because of it. I think there may be copper leeching out of the sand. Is it possible for blasting grit to contain such element? I have not done much research lol Just looking for a quick answer... Unfortunately I am losing 5 shrimps a day, and it is shamefully ongoing... I thought it was because of the stress of separating them while I was converting their substrate.. I don't think so... but I did not drip-acclimate them (but what is the point if the water pH, kH, gH and the temperature is the same?) I just poured them in.. So anyway, they eat like normal shrimps do, but the sudden deaths are driving my crazy. I am giving them the best Reverse Osmosis soft water that is given back important electrolytes, so the acidity of ther water remains the same when I swapped out ADA AS2 for blasting grit and cold temps available.. The reason I had to use sand grit was because ADA Amazonia 2 was beginning to turn into serious mush like dirt; so I had a plan to cap it with something new, blasting black grit... Before, things were fine with Amazonia 2, but shortly after, the shrimps was digging and looking for detritus, and it generated clouds upon clouds of Amazonia 2 dust, which tells me its probably because of the age of the soil, which is about 3 years old now. It is finally starting to seriously break down...

Do you guys think it is the sand grit containing copper? I am seriously thinking about buying a copper test kit by API to check and see if there are high levels of it. Also, I might consider taking out the sand for a different type that is shrimp-safe (which brand is good in your experience?) if the blasting grit is no good.

Any thoughts or help would greatly be appreciated.

Thanks for reading guys,

-William
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,121 Posts
Have you checked for ammonia in the water? If you removed all the substrate and put the shrimp into a tank with only new substrate, you may have upset the biofilter and ammonia may be the culprit.


I do not know about the blasting grit, though. In your case I would take some of the grit and tank water, put both in a bag or jar, shake it up real good a few times, and have the water tested at an LFS if they have a copper kit.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
93 Posts
Most blasting grit that I have used is aluminum oxide or silica based; I don’t know how aluminum will affect shrimp. The blasting grit is not meant to be used for anything more than taking off dirt so I would bet that the QA for checking the content of other contaminates isn’t there. Copper, aluminum, iron, steel shavings and dust could be found in my last shop and we didn’t deal with anything but steel. Contamination is always there.

Where did you get the media from? You could try mixing PFS and another black sand to get a nice effect from your substrate if you are thinking of changing it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
618 Posts
depends on what kind it is. there is some that is made of copper slag and some coal slag.

Ebony grit is copper slag. blackblast and black beauty are coal slag and from what i see on the msds sheets, they don't contain copper. i have heard of blasting grit piercing the shrimp's shells, but idk if it is true or not.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,588 Posts
Discussion Starter · #6 ·
D'oh!

The problem is ammonia, and nitrite... You guys were right. Bah, I should have tested. The whole time thought it was high levels of copper.. I assumed the biological filter was holding enough colonies of beneficial bacteria to handle the cycle, I guess the filter wasn't enough to do the job.. it can't hold all of it, some probably established in dense amounts on the Amazonia 2 substrate...

So for now as an emergency, I am dosing x2 of Prime, used seachem's Stability & Purigen, and a bit of gunk from other filters in hopes of removing ammonia and nitrite immediately..

I will give you guys an update later. I have to go to work. :eek:

Thanks a lot guys for helping out.

-Will
 
1 - 8 of 8 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top