Seems like it is a beauty is in the eye of the beholder situation. From what I have learned, it can be managed to be snuffed out. It canbalso be let go and snuff out a whole aquarium. There has to to be some sort of a throttle to its growth.
Am I just talking myself into an experiment?
😂 I'm already in my own with my 40b. I know there's a piece of driftwood in there making a mess (it's decomposing) and the tank is in direct sunlight.. Algae experiments are fun. I've got my tank as controlled with algae as I can (ferts are balanced, water quality is spot on). Algae is 100% predictable in that tank- I know exactly what type and where it will show up.
I 100% agree with your reasoning, but, yes, you are talking yourself into an experiment. You will have a ton of fun, but you may crash a tank doing so. If you do decide to do this experiment I suggest using as basic as you can for a tank set up and play with 1 influence at a time. Forgo co2 until the end (if you bother with it) and use and inert substrate with root tabs where needed. This will give you, personally, the most influence on the composition of your water. I would LOVE to see this play out lol