The Planted Tank Forum banner

Am I overstocking?

736 Views 3 Replies 3 Participants Last post by  Bill Brasky
I currently have:

9 Harlequin Rasboras
9 Boy Guppies
2 Pearl Gourami
2 SAE
2 Zebra Loaches
1 Powder Blue Gourami.

I'm looking at another school of cardinal tetra... around 10-15 fish. I have a 38 gallon tank. My LFS says I should be ok because of my plants, but I'm not so sure.

:help:
1 - 4 of 4 Posts
well, before you add more fish, keep in mind that the Gouramis and SEA will grow to 3-6" within a year. I worry that full grown Pearls won't behave themselves with three dozen 1.0-1.5" fish scurrying around the tank, so you may want to return them before adding those cardinals. of course, fish behavior will vary by fish and tank.

overstocking a tank is relative to the filtration and maintenance you are willing to do, not so much the number of fish. so if you have a good filter with good media, and are willing to do 50% water changes and filter media rinses weekly, then you should be fine.
IMO you're not overstocked. As long as you stick with a small tetra for the school you should be fine. I'd look into something like Glolights, Neons, or Black Neons.
well, before you add more fish, keep in mind that the Gouramis and SEA will grow to 3-6" within a year. I worry that full grown Pearls won't behave themselves with three dozen 1.0-1.5" fish scurrying around the tank, so you may want to return them before adding those cardinals. of course, fish behavior will vary by fish and tank.

overstocking a tank is relative to the filtration and maintenance you are willing to do, not so much the number of fish. so if you have a good filter with good media, and are willing to do 50% water changes and filter media rinses weekly, then you should be fine.
My Pearls are almost 5 inches long right now while the Blue is about 3 inches. the SAE's are almost 4 inches as well. I have been thinking about returning them once they grow up.

I've got a HOB Penguin 200 (i think). It's good for 50 gallons. I already do the weekly 50% change and filter clean with a filter replacement every month.

I guess it's just time to wait for my LFS to get some smaller fish in :icon_smil
1 - 4 of 4 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top