The Planted Tank Forum banner
1 - 9 of 9 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
18 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Getting ready to get my 75 and have been amazed at the horrible reviews for basically every brand available in glass, I realize your dissatisfied customer is more apt to review so usually take these at face value, also expect many were not set up properly or unlevel etc. That said does anyone have any recent experience with the quality of Aqueons larger tanks, All glass used to be amazing but I keep reading they have cut quality over the years and wasn’t sure how these were holding up today.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
5,100 Posts
Aqueon tanks have gone up in quality in my experience not down. The glass is now more likely to be cut evenly without overlap in the corners and the silicone seams are at least straight now whereas before they were goopy.

Anyway, I said this in another thread recently but I will say it here as well. Most of the problems people have with these tanks are that they either 1) don't put them on a flat surface (note, flat, not level) and/or 2) they put a mat or Styrofoam under a rimmed tank which puts pressure on places that's not designed to have pressure. Mats are for rimless tanks, not rimmed.

A lot of people are also building their own stands now and frankly, doing a terrible job of it. When their tank bursts a seam after 6 months they blame the tank maker as opposed to themselves for making an uneven stand. Or they measure and check for flatness in their garage where they built the stand. Then bring it into their house and don't check again, not realizing their floors in their house are not flat and their stand will torque to follow that pattern. etc.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
17 Posts
I see alot of stands made out of 2"×4" and it makes me cringe. Why you ask? When we frame a wall we look for the crown in the boards and line them so they all crown the same way. This makes the dry wall flatter and make less wow in the wall. So yeah, let's use boards that have a bend in them to make an aquarium stand and try to make it flat. Choosing the the right materials might make a difference in the finish. Remember the finish is only as good as the foundation. Proper 3/4" plywood design will work just fine for an aquarium stand. Forget trying to cut with a hand saw and find a cabinet shop to cut your parts. Most of their saws are flat and square to within .005" of an inch. Or just find a shop that can make the whole cabinet for you. Unless you have the equipment or the skills you should hire someone that has the equipment and experience. Dimensional lumber that is flat and straight might be a better option but many balk at the price. You can buy aluminum stands that you can assemble and that is a great choice. Tenecor Aquariums makes them now as well as some other companies like Innovative Marine. Avoid any stands made out of iron, particle board, or MDF. I have seen very few stands made out of these materials that the customer does not live to regret. Iron often deforms under load and during the welding process. The other two materials start to fail after they get wet...and they will get wet.

Whatever you choose remember that a 75 gallon of freshwater water is about 626lbs plus the sand, rocks, glass, lights and you see the possible issues. A average residential floor live load is 40lbs per square foot or about .28lbs per square inch. So the stand or cabinet should distribute that load to the floor in a way that does not exceed the per square foot requirement. In this case it would be better to place this tank on a concrete floor or make sure the floor is rated to your load. I have never personally seen a 75 gallon tank cause a floor problem in a modern construction home. This is because the tank is against a wall in most cases and often a bearing wall. It is not a bad idea to know the direction your floor joist run and place the tank and stand perpendicular to the joists. Floor bracing might be an option if you have a crawl space.

The brand of tank is dependent on your level of risk. If you are risk averse look at acrylic tanks that have a longer term warranty or a glass company that has a longer term warranty. Most mass produced tanks have short warranty periods due to the fact the average user has the tank up less than 18 months and sells it in a garage sale. Inspect the seams of the tank to make sure the bonds are clear or bubble free. This is harder to do with the black silicone seams but you can still see voids and they should be avoided. In most cases you should expect many years of trouble free enjoyment no matter what brand you choose.

After getting so wordy I saw your other thread and noticed your excellent stand building skills lol! Just disregard my ignorance for posting about stand design as you got it knocked. The stand looks like it weights more than the tank! Nice!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
18 Posts
Discussion Starter · #9 ·
After getting so wordy I saw your other thread and noticed your excellent stand building skills lol! Just disregard my ignorance for posting about stand design as you got it knocked. The stand looks like it weights more than the tank! Nice!
Lol thanks, while I’ve built stands for tanks up to 300 gallons before, I’ve learned no building is ever level or as flush as you want it, and wood no mater how good can warp, bow, or ever so slightly shift as you put it all together. I definitely overbuild for that reason, and level, level, re-level lol.
Ended up getting a deal on a clear for life 75 gallon so going to go acrylic for this build. Once cycling I’ll be rebuilding an entertainment center/nano tank wall as a project with my son
 
1 - 9 of 9 Posts
Top