The Planted Tank Forum - View Single Post - Which ADA liquid ferts do I need if I'm going to use ADA only ferts?
View Single Post
post #4 of (permalink) Old 03-01-2009, 03:32 PM
hokuryu
Planted Tank Obsessed
 
PTrader: (3/100%)
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Chicago, IL
Posts: 423
Quote:
Originally Posted by eyebeatbadgers View Post
Are you sure it's the fertilizers, and not something else?

Here are some tanks that use EI, no name brands needed:

*****


There's more to the equation than what company makes your fertilizers.
Man, those are beautiful, eyebeat. I agree with you - elements and compounds are elements and compounds, and plant physiology is well established. As much as I respect and use Seachem as a company, for instance, pretty tough to justify spending something like 44X the price of dry ferts. From Rex Grigg's site:

Quote:
Why would you want to use bulk nutrients. Well here are some numbers.
  • If you are dosing 60gallons of water with Flourish Potassium you would need 100 ml to get to 20 ppm.
  • If you are dosing 60 gallons of water with Flourish Phosphorus you would need to dose 48 ml to get to 1 ppm.
  • If you are dosing 60 gallons of water with Flourish Nitrogen you would need to dose 30 ml to get to 10 ppm.
  • Flourish Potassium is $6 mail order for 500 ml. So if you dose once a week that bottle will last you 5 weeks. Cost would $1.25 a week to dose potassium.
  • Flourish Phosphorus is $7.50 mail order for 500 ml. So if you dose once a week that bottle would last you 10 weeks. Cost would be 75 a week to dose Phosphorus.
  • Seachem Nitrogen is $7.50 mail order for 500 ml. So if you dose once a week that bottle will last you 16 weeks. Cost would be 47 a week to dose nitrates.
  • Total cost for one dose a week with Seachem $~2.75. Note there is no shipping factored in here and there are some rounding errors.

To dose the same tank with bulk nutrients.
  • Nitrates 2 a dose.
  • Phosphates .2 a dose. Note that is 5 doses for a penny.
  • Total cost for one dose a week with dry nutrients 6.2

Seachem products cost 44X as much per week. Note these prices do not include shipping charges and there are some rounding errors. So that pretty much settles that one.
And I think the same holds for ADA. It all comes down to value - not price, to me - what value for what outlay?
hokuryu is offline  
 
 
For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome