A.K.A. Fish Room Bum
Join Date: Jan 2017
Location: Davis, CA Fish out of water.
Dirt vs others such as ADA or Stratum or Inert using Tabs or other Non-Dirt
I used dirt for nearly a year and there were some amazing results with it, with the exception of maybe a few carpeted plants, but I attribute the failures on that front to my lack of experience and more than likely, lighting in particular.
After a nice run with my dirted (Miracle Grow Tank), it's time to clean it up and let it go. [/U]
Pros. Seems like practically anything grew without very much effort and I never put in ferts with the exception of an occasional Excel but even that wasn't needed and I quickly stopped with that. At first, I was pumping in Co2, this tank was growing like it was on fire. I turned off the Co2 and the plants continued to grow. I was using a two 6500K Marineland Plant LCD lights on a 55Gal tank. I grew a wide variety of plants, stems, s. repens, Ludwigia, Rotalia, Val, Amazon Sword, drawf hair grass,Tall Grass species and then some. I had Cherry Barbs, Roseline Sharks, Corydoras, Golden Zebra Loaches, clown plecos and a few others, here and there.
Cons. Algae war was uncontrollable and after a while, the algae war was lost and I grew tired of running a large UV sterilizer non-stop. I have a lot more fun with my non-dirted tanks because they are less damage control and I spend more time having fun and being creative. By dirt, I don't consider Fluval Stratum or ADA Aquasoil as it's an engineered, mana-made product whereas as dirt and Miracle Grow is albeit not entirely natural and it's produced, it's much closer comparison to "actual" dirt or top soil. I have a tank right now with Stratum that is doing great, I'm also in the process of doing a large low-tech setup that will have an inert substrate and or Stratum or ADA Aquasoil of some type.
To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
Last edited by DigityDog70; 09-04-2017 at 08:09 PM.