Polishing out lots of scratches is a lot of hard work. If you are willing and able to do the work, I think it is well worth it, if the tank is designed to hold water, and not a reptile tank. I had a 40 gallon tank like that many years ago, and even though it was made for aquarium use, the sides bulged out too much for my comfort with it full of water. I believe they make those with thicker acrylic now, but they may make reptile versions with thinner material.