Log of Cherry Shrimp Chat
Planted Tank Forums
Your Tanks Image Hosting *Tank Tracker * Plant Profiles Fish Profiles Planted Tank Guide Photo Gallery Articles

Go Back   The Planted Tank Forum > Specific Aspects of a Planted Tank > Shrimp & Other Invertebrates


Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 09-19-2004, 02:48 PM   #1
gnatster
Planted Tank Obsessed
 
PTrader: (2/100%)
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Plano, TX
Posts: 488
Default

Log of Cherry Shrimp Chat


Below is the log from the chat this past Wenesday. I cleaned it up a little but it still is pretty much in raw chat format.

<Momotaro> My, and some others have found CR do better in a larger aquarium
<Shay> Hello!
<Jumbotummy> aw
<Momotaro> A 10 should work, but they seem to really thrive and reproduce much better in a larger aquarium
<Shay> Congrat, Gnatster
<Momotaro> What type of plants Jumbo?
<gnatster> I am breeding cherries pretty darn successfully and am willing to share what I have learned, even thought it would kill my market in time
<Jumbotummy> rotala indica, dwarf hairgrass,
<Jumbotummy> uhhmm
<Jumbotummy> lots
<Jumbotummy> I got a pic somewhere
<Momotaro> Sounds good Jumbo
<Momotaro> They love cover
<Momotaro> Baby tears, Riccia moss Java moss
<zapus> mine stay in the moss wall
<gnatster> I don't know about that Momo. the tank I use is 1/2 filled with java moss, yet I see them quite a bit on the bare open substrate
<Momotaro> I have found when they can get underneath something, they really feel safe
<Momotaro> When they feel safe , they really reproduce
<Jumbotummy> (Link: http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v4...uff/Sept6C.jpg)http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v4...uff/Sept6C.jpg
<Momotaro> I mean REALLY! Right Gnat
<gnatster> then again this is in a shrimp only tank
<Shay> How do they reproduce? Live?
<Momotaro> They are egg layers
<gnatster> Well the male and the female....
<Momotaro> The female will hold the eggs in her swimmerettes
<Shay> lol
<Momotaro> She fans them and moves them about her body
<gnatster> The female is fertilized when she molts
<Momotaro> Keeps them moving to prevent the eggs from dying
<Shay> I'm a little old for that talk but guess I had it coming
<Jumbotummy> hahaha
*** Signoff: Jumbotummy (Quit: Jumbotummy)
<Momotaro> * If you remember the post by John P about his shrimp that died...
<Momotaro> He pulled the eggs off of the dead shrimp
<gnatster> when she still has a soft shell the male mounts her, many males try and mate with a newly molted female
<Momotaro> Now, I havenít heard how they did, but I imagine they died because he couldn't move them and keep them alive like Mama shrimp
<gnatster> yeah I haven't seen any updates
<gnatster> but the female fans the eggs constantly
<Momotaro> I hope it worked, but I doubt it
<Momotaro> The eggs are big
<Momotaro> and Yellow
<gnatster> about 15-20 per brood
<zapus> Iíve heard of people putting cray eggs on a sponge filter
<Momotaro> The large eggs are what makes this shrimp so viable and prolific
<Momotaro> The large egg ensures the larvae develop rapidly
<gnatster> as they bear young that are mini shrimps, not planktonic larvae
<Momotaro> The shrimp exits the egg as a shrimp, unlike the Amanos
<gnatster> I'll shut up
<Momotaro> They are as gnat said a smaller shrimp
<Shay> Please don't
<Momotaro> LOL Gnat, I am a slow typist
<Jumbotummy> wow nice detailed description...
<Momotaro> Keep going dude
<gnatster> I have a pic lemme get it
<Shay> I'm learning a lot
<Momotaro> That is where a lot of cover comes in handy
<Momotaro> Go on Gnat
<zapus> long as it's not shrimpie porn
<gnatster> ohh sorry, looking for pic
<Momotaro> The infant shrimp hide in good thick plants
<Shay> Can they be kept with any type of fish? i.e. will angels eat them?
<Momotaro> Angels will more than likely gobble them up
<Shay> Adult or just young?
<Momotaro> When I trim my Riccia, all the tetras fly down to the bottom of the aquarium for a quick snack
<gnatster> Angels will thank you for the shrimp and come back asking for more
<gnatster> however it will color the angel up real nice
<Momotaro> I would think angels will eat 'em all,. young and old
<Momotaro> Heck, angels will eat neons, right?
<gnatster> Baby Shrimps, sorry for the bad pic, they are SMALL (Link: http://www.plantedtank.net/imageh/im...aby_Cherry.JPG)http://www.plantedtank.net/imageh/im...aby_Cherry.JPG
<Shay> Anything they can get in their greedy little mouths
<gnatster> substrate is eco complete so you have a size gauge
<Momotaro> Foreground plants like Riccia, Baby tears, Java moss help the babies hide from the hungry masses
<gnatster> Baby on sponge (Link: http://www.plantedtank.net/imageh/im...air_Babies.JPG)http://www.plantedtank.net/imageh/im...air_Babies.JPG
<Momotaro> They are tiny little guys!
<Momotaro> They need hiding places!
<gnatster> baby and 1 month old (Link: http://www.plantedtank.net/imageh/im...9/DSCN0609.JPG)http://www.plantedtank.net/imageh/im...9/DSCN0609.JPG
<Shay> Sorry, can't see pics
<Momotaro> Great shots Gnat!
<Jumbotummy> those are some Small shrimps
<gnatster> sorry Shay, and Thanks momo
<Fender963> Shay just double click on the link
<gnatster> Preg female (Link: http://www.plantedtank.net/imageh/im...avy_w_Eggs.JPG)http://www.plantedtank.net/imageh/im...avy_w_Eggs.JPG
<Momotaro> They are absolutely tiny Jumbotummy
<Shay> Thanks, Fender.
<Shay> Angels will definitely eat 'em
<gnatster> neons will eat them
<Momotaro> I would eat them! LOL!
<Shay> lol
<Shay> that's what my hubby said
<zapus> cherries on the barbie
<Momotaro> That is why you need cover for those little ones
<Fender963> np shay
<Momotaro> I don't think you can let them fend for themselves
<gnatster> Not to contradict the cover theory, but in a dedicated shrimpery, they wander about
<Momotaro> Provide cover, don't just let them hide
<zapus> feeding those little guys must be a pain
<gnatster> feeding is easy
<Momotaro> That is, if you want to successfully breed them
<Jumbotummy> what would u feed them?
<Momotaro> Very easy
<gnatster> everything and anything
<gnatster> and lots of it
<Momotaro> My words exactly!
<zapus> lots of water changes too?
<Momotaro> They love the left over food in my foreground plants
<Momotaro> Everything does well with a waterchange
<gnatster> shrimp pellets, spinach, mustard greens, sinking pellets of any type, algae wafers
<gnatster> ahh but water changes are tricky as the shrimp are so small
<Momotaro> I have found that the shrimp really love to comb over fine leaved plants
<Momotaro> Waterchange!
<Momotaro> If you have lots of babies, tie a bit of pantyhose over your siphon's intake
<gnatster> I use airline tubing and am very careful to hang in open water only
<Momotaro> I do that when I have Killie fry
<Momotaro> Airline for your shrimp only Gnat?
<gnatster> for the siphon
<gnatster> not setting any quick water change records there
<Momotaro> I use pantyhose on my planted communities when I see lots of baby shrimp
<gnatster> change about 4 gal of 20 every week
<Momotaro> Have you found your shrimp prefer certain plants Gnat?
*** Vinlo (Vinlo@IRChat-807E87C4.home.cgocable.net) has joined channel #theplantedtankchat
<gnatster> Java Moss
<Fender963> hey vinlo
<gnatster> they love java moss
<Vinlo> good show
<Momotaro> Vin!
<Vinlo> what'd I miss?
<Momotaro> Like I said earlier, they really seem to love fine leaved plants
<Momotaro> myriophylliums
<Momotaro> Riccia
<Momotaro> Blyxa japnica
<Momotaro> Cyperus helferi
<gnatster> I have about mass of java moss that takes up 1/2 a 20l and they love it in there
<Momotaro> hair grass
<gnatster> females with eggs tend to hide deep in it
<Momotaro> They love to spend their time combing finer leaved plants in search of an algal snack!
<gnatster> while the males cavort all over the tank
<Momotaro> Males are always cavorting
<Vinlo> gnat, what filter your have on that tank? just an HOB?
<gnatster> nah, a sponge filter
<Shay> so are females, momo
<Vinlo> air driven?
<Momotaro> LOL shay!
<gnatster> yes a small air drive filter
<Vinlo> pretty low tech I guess eh?
<Momotaro> There shouldn't be any problem running a canister filter with CRs
<gnatster> besides java moss there is duckweed (bah) and Riccia floating on the surface
<Momotaro> The ones that get sucked into the canister seem to do pretty darn well inside the filter
<gnatster> that is duckweed bah
<Vinlo> what light you have over the tank PC?
<Geo> I can only imagine how bad duckweed is if it's worse than salvania
<gnatster> till they meet the impeller that is
<Fender963> okay sorry guys i'm afraid i have to depart, enjoy the chat
<gnatster> shrimp mousse!!1
<Shay> g'nite
<Vinlo> nite
<gnatster> See ya
<Momotaro> CRS seem to survive just fine inside canister filters
<Momotaro> So long Kyle
<gnatster> 2 x 13w 6700K PC
<Vinlo> mike; how do you pick the small one out?
<Fender963> good night
*** Signoff: Fender963 (Quit: Fender963)
<Momotaro> Night
<Vinlo> of the filter that is
<Momotaro> I pull the shrimp out when I clean the canister
<Geo> *reads some of the chat backlog*
<gnatster> I have it all logged Geo
<Vinlo> geo, how?
<Momotaro> pull out the media, leave the water
<Geo> I scrolled up
<Momotaro> I then pour the water from the canister through a fish net and then into a bucket
<gnatster> Zapus, as chat moderator you are logging all this, correct?
<zapus> whups
<Geo> See I am keeping 6 cherry reds in a 7 gallon minibow right now
<zapus> i was just the first one here
<Geo> Throughout the entire summer ... not even a single egg
<Momotaro> Pick them carefully out of the net vin
*** amandahuggenkiss (amanda@IRChat-5908AB8C.vc.shawcable.net) has joined channel #theplantedtankchat
<Vinlo> whew.. sounds like fun.
<amandahuggenkiss> hey guys
<Jumbotummy> hi
<gnatster> howdy
<Shay> Hello!
<zapus> lo manda
<Vinlo> ahoy hoy
<Momotaro> It is tedious, but it pays dividends
<Momotaro> The hard part is picking shrimp out of the net
<Momotaro> and thats not that bad
<Vinlo> next time i clean the filter I will be more diligent, less lazy
<amandahuggenkiss> we talking shrimp in the filter?
<Momotaro> a little diligence will pay of in spades and CRS
<Vinlo> how long can they live outta the water?
<Momotaro> about as long as a fish
<gnatster> hmm, don't know, haven't tried to see
<Momotaro> although I have pulled the out of clippings
<Geo> Fish are rather amazing sometimes
<Vinlo> gnat, you have enough.. time it for us.. hehe JK
<Momotaro> as are CRS! LOL
<gnatster> no problem Vinlo, and that from ones you want ...right?
<Geo> Had a pygmy cory live for at least a half hour out of the water, under some wet driftwood that I picked out of the tank
<Vinlo> what about that crazy snakehead fish, it can travel from pond to pond
<Geo> think it was closer to hour and a half >_<
<Momotaro> i never though to leave a CRS out to see how long it would live! LOL
<Geo> X_x;
<Momotaro> How did we do?
<Momotaro> any questions?
<amandahuggenkiss> yeah, can you repeat everything I missed ;-)
<gnatster> Yea, got any Crystal Shrimp?
<Momotaro> That would be nice!
<Geo> Why aren't my shrimp breeding
<Shay> Still trying to decide if its worth trying to keep some
<Momotaro> I think it is, provided you don't have fish that are going to eat them
<Vinlo> Yeah, when is amanda going to send me some of those green shrimp heeh
<gnatster> amanda, pm me you email, I'll send a log
<Momotaro> They are very attractive, and downright fun to watch
<Geo> I think my betta will make a nice snack out of any babies he finds...
<amandahuggenkiss> thanks gnat - sounds like I missed some stuff
<Momotaro> Send one to Kyle too Gnat
<Shay> I have four angels in that tank - they won't last long
<amandahuggenkiss> vin, I'll hook you up as soon as I'm happy with how many I have
<gnatster> ok, should I edit the log and post it then?
<Vinlo> geo, could be the tank is too small. I have heard that of the shrimp. People having no luck with the smaller tanks
<Momotaro> I think he might to Geo, IF you don't give the babies a place to hide
<Vinlo> amanda, thanks! Hehe
<Geo> I am growing a lot more xmass moss
<Geo> But ... that smaller tank thing
<Geo> a Minibow ... could that be the reason ya think?
<Momotaro> We did touch base on tank size at the beginning
<gnatster> I can edit the log in the next couple of days and post it if yall like
<Shay> BTW, you guys did a great job. Thank you
<Momotaro> Good idea Gnat
<Vinlo> I just remember reading that someone had 2 tanks with shrimp, a 20 and 10g, no luck in the 10 and a fecundity of shrimp in the 20
<Geo> Momotaro, yea, I saw that
<Geo> Well, it's very interesting
<Momotaro> Thanks Shay...Thanks to gnat
<gnatster> I may have to experiment with that, I have a spare 10
<Geo> I was hoping to breed them for my LFS, so they could get some stock and start breeding them themselves
<Vinlo> I could be on crack though
<Geo> Well I've had mine since last spring
<Geo> and I've never even seen an egg
<Geo> One of mine is turning a darker color as well, very weird
<Momotaro> How many shrimp are you housing?
<Geo> dark grey
<Geo> 8
<Geo> 6-8
<gnatster> I have found that 99% of the lfs's don't want cherry shrimp as they sell slow and only to plant geeks, taking up space that could be used by faster moving fish
<Momotaro> Could you possibly have no males?
<Geo> I thought of that
<Vinlo> gnat; most places won't carry _any_ freshwater shrimp IME
<Momotaro> Or no females
<Geo> Do you have pics of either?
<Shay> Is there an ideal temp range for them?
<Geo> Don't the females differ by having a rounder bottom tail?
<Geo> and Gnatster: my LFS gets requests for them a lot
<Momotaro> it is believed the females are the really red ones
<gnatster> Alsop,if you buy cherries from a lfs chances are they are all female as they have more color and are culled by the exporter
<Momotaro> The males are not as bright or as colorful
<Geo> Ah
<Geo> I got mine from AZgardens
<Geo> but not all of them had a deep red color to start out
<Vinlo> oh yeah, Mike, I picked up that external heater from the swap and shop.. neat little gadget
<gnatster> do they breed or import?
<amandahuggenkiss> azgardens website says the opposite - that the males are redder
<Geo> breed
<gnatster> azgardens is WRONG
<Momotaro> Temperature range 72-80F, hows that Shay?
<gnatster> all mu well colored shrimp have eggs at some point and the duller one have never had eggs
<Shay> Pretty easy to accommodate
<Geo> Interesting
<Geo> accept paypal, gnatster?
<Momotaro> very easy!
<amandahuggenkiss> Both my dark coloured and pale shrimp are carrying or developing eggs
<gnatster> amanda, how did the spinach do?
<Momotaro> The paler shrimp may still be a juvenile
<amandahuggenkiss> they LOVED it!
<amandahuggenkiss> Just picked up some of those hikari crab bits too
<gnatster> ahh pale ones that are developing eggs will turn a deeper red once the eggs are being carried
<gnatster> err pale ones
<amandahuggenkiss> I gotta get some boys
<amandahuggenkiss> is there any way to sex other than colour?
<gnatster> you can see the eggs develop in the thorax, it will start to turn yellow
<Momotaro> I believe there is, but you would need to get them under a magnifying glass or a microscope
<gnatster> spread the little legs?
<Momotaro> AUGH!
<amandahuggenkiss> hee
<Shay> lol
<Momotaro> Groan!!
* gnatster keeps his day job
<Momotaro> What else?
<Geo> I am at my tank right now
<Momotaro> What else?
<Geo> Ok interesting
<Geo> one of my shrimp
<Momotaro> p
<Geo> there is a BRIGHT yellow spot under the carapace
<Momotaro> Developing eggs
<Geo> between the last 2 legs
<Geo> Those are, eh?
<gnatster> that would most likely be eggs devopling Geo
<amandahuggenkiss> looks like a little saddle
<Geo> Yea
<Geo> I see a saddle
<gnatster> it will grow in size
<Geo> ... omg ... JOY!!!!!
<Momotaro> YES! Neat description!
<amandahuggenkiss> first time I saw it I thought it might be a deficiency of some sort
<amandahuggenkiss> what with my soft water & all
<gnatster> Lets see ..other observations....with very heave feeding they will grow from shrmplets to egg carrying in about 45 days
<gnatster> I have yet to determine the gestation period
<gnatster> and I have not seen how the eggs change as they develop
<Shay> Well, thanks for the education. I need to get to bed so I can support my growing planted tank habit tomorrow.
<Geo> I think I see another one with the same saddle
<Momotaro> The more you feed them, the more you will have. Kind of like Tribbles1 LOL!
<amandahuggenkiss> hard to tell unless you segregate the pregnant ones & observe
<Momotaro> Good night Shay
<Momotaro> Thanks for dropping in!
<amandahuggenkiss> see ya shay
<Geo> I have spare 2.5 gallon tanks
<Geo> think it would be wise to set one up w/a lot of java moss and put preg females there?
<amandahuggenkiss> isn't it tough to keep shrimp in such a small tank?
<gnatster> there is talk that smaller tanks are not good
<Jumbotummy> yea time to go
*** Signoff: Jumbotummy (Quit: Jumbotummy)
<Momotaro> 2.5 is small, but if the conditions are met?????
<Vinlo> can't you get a 10g at walmart for dirt cheap anyways?
<Geo> It's more about space
<Momotaro> I tried to get Mustapha to join us, but I contacted him too late
<Momotaro> maybe next time
<Vinlo> you don't have room for a 10g? Damn, you space is tight
<gnatster> there are also 2 shrimp forums, petshrimp.com and I have to look the other one up
<Momotaro> Should we consider a shrimp forum here?
<zapus> frank greco has a listserv as well
<amandahuggenkiss> there seem to be enough people with shrimp
<gnatster> the other is a yahoo group runn by frank of (Link: http://www.franksaquarium.com/)http://www.franksaquarium.com/
<Geo> time to feed the fish
<Momotaro> I will ask kyle tonight
<amandahuggenkiss> I never know whether I should post in fish or general
<Vinlo> What do you guys think would be the best way to setup a new shrimp tank (bare bones), what from an existing tank and let the filter run for a week before adding shrimps?
<Momotaro> I am never sure either
<Momotaro> From an existing tank
<Momotaro> I wouldn't want to cycle an aquarium with them
<gnatster> Vinlo, I took a bare 20L and set up with eco comeplete from my larger tank and spng filter that sat in sump of larger tank for a week
<Vinlo> I've been saving my java moss trimings for a couple weeks now.. just incase
<Vinlo> I could do the same with one of my canisters
<zapus> gotta be up in 6, guess i'd better crash
<gnatster> added jave moss and water from a water change os a bigger tank
<amandahuggenkiss> see ya zapus
<Momotaro> Night
<Vinlo> cya zapus
<gnatster> later
*** Signoff: zapus (Quit: )
*** Signoff: alias (Quit: alias)
<Vinlo> just need a light and a tank and I think I am set
<gnatster> then added 50 adult shrimp
<gnatster> and viola, shrimp breeder
<Vinlo> I can't add that many.. hehe.. just add 'em as I find 'em
<amandahuggenkiss> how many shrimp do you guys think you have in your tanks?
<Momotaro> Laurel, my LFS had P. gertrudae
<Vinlo> I don't even want to guess. But a lot more than I first thought I had
<gnatster> I counted over 100 1cm or smaller ones last night
<Geo> my LFS has them too ... gertrudes, that is
<amandahuggenkiss> Momo - did you get some?
<amandahuggenkiss> are they as pretty in person??
<Momotaro> I have to have about 200
<Geo> I have 7-8 shrimp in my tank
<Momotaro> No I didn't
<Momotaro> They didn't look sthat good in person
<Momotaro> they weren't displaying
<gnatster> and about 40 adults
<gnatster> I'm about to try and ship babies and see how it goes
<amandahuggenkiss> I've only got maybe 10-ish each of cherries & green
<gnatster> let me try again
<Momotaro> Thats not bad Laurel
<gnatster> I am about to try and ship babies and see how it goes
<Momotaro> you should have more CRS soon enough
<amandahuggenkiss> It's tough to count when they're hiding in the hairgrass & crypts!
<amandahuggenkiss> if I have any males, I should have some...
<Vinlo> damn gnat, that wasn't even close the first time
<amandahuggenkiss> lol
<gnatster> right, so I figure if I see about 100 on the bare substrate I can safely say there are 50 more in the moss
<Vinlo> probably more gnat
<gnatster> yeah, but I would rather under estimate
<Vinlo> hehe
<amandahuggenkiss> what size tank, gnat?
<gnatster> 20 long
<amandahuggenkiss> holy crap!
<Vinlo> that is a lot of scrumps
<amandahuggenkiss> I can't even imagine that many in my 20
<Momotaro> I've got to get moving!
<amandahuggenkiss> awww, see ya mo
<Momotaro> I have to check the board and then get to bed
<gnatster> see ya, thanks for the info
<Vinlo> as do I, take it easy. Thanks all for the info. Happy Shrimping
<Momotaro> Thanks to you too Gnat
<Momotaro> Thanks for dropping in everyone!
<Momotaro> Happy shrimping!
__________________
-*-*-*-*-
gnatster
gnatster is offline   Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
Advertisement
 
Old 09-19-2004, 08:29 PM   #2
KyleT
Planted Tank VIP
 
KyleT's Avatar
 
PTrader: (5/100%)
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: Austin, Texas
Posts: 13,533
Default

Thanx for posting it Gnatster. What program irc program are you using?

Kyle
__________________
Please Send all Support Requests to forumadmin
Bit Of Nothing - Personal Blog
KyleT is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-19-2004, 08:59 PM   #3
gnatster
Planted Tank Obsessed
 
PTrader: (2/100%)
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Plano, TX
Posts: 488
Default

Trillian, combines all my chat clients in easy to use interface
__________________
-*-*-*-*-
gnatster
gnatster is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Wed. Chat: Cherry Red Shrimp Momotaro The Lounge & Introductions 10 10-01-2004 04:27 AM
cherry shrimp breeding pufferfreak Shrimp & Other Invertebrates 0 08-07-2004 06:51 PM
Question, pregnet cherry red shrimp sailblue5 Fish 3 08-06-2004 04:16 AM
Cherry shrimp and cories Fishbulb General Planted Tank Discussion 7 07-04-2004 08:39 PM


All times are GMT. The time now is 08:30 PM.


Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright Planted Tank LLC 2012