Would you change the right side?

[Kai808]

Hi everyone,

I got a Mr. aqua 12 gallon in dsm mode and was wondering if you think this is scape is balanced. I'm trying to portray two islands. I like the left side but not quite sure about the right side. What do you guys think?



FTS


left side


right side


Thanks for looking!

[cawolf86]

I love it and am no aquascaper but here is my rough interpretation.

The two islands have similar shapes but the one on the right has the rocks spaced rather than overlapped and the prominent "pointy" rock acts as a focal point which takes away from the stunning left.

Maybe move the rocks on right closer together and angle the "pointy" rock differently so it isn't the main focal point?

[jcgd]

I like it, but I think it might look better if you swap the two large rocks on the right so that the focal point, the tall, pointy rock, is closer to center. It's a super cool scape though. Looks HUGE! I can't believe that's 12 gallons.

[Kai808]

Originally Posted by cawolf86

I love it and am no aquascaper but here is my rough interpretation.

The two islands have similar shapes but the one on the right has the rocks spaced rather than overlapped and the prominent "pointy" rock acts as a focal point which takes away from the stunning left.

Maybe move the rocks on right closer together and angle the "pointy" rock differently so it isn't the main focal point?

Thanks for the feedback! The two rocks are actually touching but there is AS on top of it.

I like it, but I think it might look better if you swap the two large rocks on the right so that the focal point, the tall, pointy rock, is closer to center. It's a super cool scape though. Looks HUGE! I can't believe that's 12 gallons.

I'm glad you like it. I think if I switch it, the large rock might look like a sore thumb. I am realizing that the tall stone doesn't fit. i'm going to replace it. It's going to be pita because the rocks are sitting on the glass and holding up the back soil. But better now then later. Thanks again.

[ChadRamsey]

no way. i wouldnt change a thing. great choice in stones and great placement. they have great "flow", all to the left. well balanced imo. i think that you did a GREAT job on the scape and i cant wait to see it all filled in.

[Kai808]

Originally Posted by ChadRamsey

no way. i wouldnt change a thing. great choice in stones and great placement. they have great "flow", all to the left. well balanced imo. i think that you did a GREAT job on the scape and i cant wait to see it all filled in.

Thanks for the response but Oops... Sorry, I found a better stone and replaced it. I think I'm happier with it. Hopefully I can post the new pictures and start a journal.