|12-03-2002, 03:11 PM||#16|
Planted Tank VIP
Man, I hate that I missed out on this discussion while I was gone!
I think you guys are on track. Make small adjustments to the CO2, raising it a small amount at a time to see how the fish and plants respond. I've got as much light as you, though, and only have DIY CO2 (resulting in 6-10ppm) and I don't have the hair algae problems you describe.
While raising CO2 levels might get your plants to pearl, to get them to really grow, you need to leave those macronutrients in your water. I use PhosZorb myself, but only occasionally, when phosphate levels get out of control (more than 1.0ppm) due to disturbing a Jobe's stick in the substrate, or a dirty filter or an old piece of driftwood.
The biggest evidence of nutrient starvation is that Amazon Swords. Those things are pigs. If your Nitrates are below 5ppm, they will do horribly. I try to keep mine actually above 10ppm by adding KNO3 (stump remover) weekly.
Those Dupla Tabs are great, and will keep that substrate enriched. Your substrate is getting better with time, not worse. Jobe's sticks will provide even more potassium and much needed Nitrates to those root feeders. It will supply some phosphate as well, but you don't want to get rid of all of it. Let the plants do their job.
You've got a good understanding of higher order plants competing for nutrients against lower algae, you've just got to let it develop into practice in your tank! When nutrient levels drop, plants will suffer. Algae can survive and even thrive in amazingly low nutrient levels. Eliminating nutrients is a bad way to get rid of algae.
Get those good low range NO3 and PO4 test kits, raise CO2 in small increments every few days, and try some low Phosphate fertilizer sticks to get those Swords happy. Good Luck!
- Sam P -
plantedtanker in limbo - all tanks currently in storage
|12-18-2002, 04:38 AM||#17|
Here's a brief update...
Those companies that say their filter carbon is phosphate free... They lie!
I could add phos-guard and the phosphate level would drop some but it would come right back up to over 2 ppm.
I pulled out the carbon, and replaced it with SeaChem's Renew. I also put in some fresh phos-guard. Phosphate is now at about .7 ppm. The hair algae is looking pissed off and some of the strands have broken free and collected on the filter intake screen. Dare I say it? I think it might be DYING!
The higher plants are looking better and making O2 more prolificly. The swords are putting out new leaves.
The Lamotte titrator says CO2 is at 47 ppm.... Which the fish don't seem to mind a bit, btw.
Red Sea low range Nitrate test says Nitrates are ZERO. I'm tempted to VERY CAREFULLY add some Yamato Green-N and see if:
a) Algae stays in check
b) The Nitrate level comes up to a detectable level
c) The plants (expecially the swords) are happier.
I'm afraid to jinx it by saying that things are on the mend... so I won't.
(But that's what I think.) <-- Fate can't read what you type in parenthesis.
Chief 51, Engine 511, Engine 513, Rescue 511, respond to an algae outbreak at...
|Thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|Hair algae and brush algae||fedge||Algae||2||06-01-2004 07:08 PM|
|My algae problems||depthC||Algae||1||03-07-2004 07:07 PM|
|hair algae taking care of itself?||MD2B||Algae||3||02-01-2004 02:39 AM|
|Hair Algae Case Study- Long||ken6217||General Planted Tank Discussion||4||01-18-2004 10:17 PM|
|Hagen CO2 and hair algae question||ming||General Planted Tank Discussion||10||12-15-2003 02:36 PM|