I made a trip out to the Brook Park Location off of Engle saturday. Decent selection. Came hom with 3 furcata rainbows, an Otocinclus, and A micro sword. The guy who helped me was super helpful, and i didn't have to wait around for someone to help me. I was a little disappointed they didn't have any HC, and didn't have any gobies at all, but overall, a pretty good experience. I used to go to the mentor location (way closer to my house), its a shame they closed. I'll have to check out Something Fishy and the place independence.
As for Aquatic Technology, they're fantastic. My dad bought a saltwater setup from them with live rock, some fish, and a few shrimp. They got him totally set up. Would definitely recommend.
There used to be a store on Ridge road right off 480, but they must've closed. I remember them having a really nice selection of fish, and a huge plant tank.