So I made a Google Map of all of the Pet Stores listed in this thread. It can be found here:
For right now, I haven't allowed open editing of this map - but if anyone would like to help keep the map maintained (hint hint acitydweller) - shoot me your email in a PM and I can add you as a collaborator; collaborators will also be allowed to invite others able to edit the map.
The color scheme is based on the number of smiley faces in the list - and that should probably be updated as people visit them. I visited a handful of the Jersey places a few weeks back - and several were very nice, but I can't remember which is which
I also added a couple of new ones that weren't on the list:
Franks Aquarium (just posted as Lindenhurst - not home address as it isn't a storefront - so that people can at least see the general area)
Exotic Pet Warehouse, Yonkers, NY
597 Central Park Avenue Yonkers, NY 10704
Large selection of FW (not a lot of nanofish) and SW - but the place is dirty, tanks not incredibly clean
2574 East Tremont Ave.
Bronx, NY 10461
Haven't been there yet, but was recommended by another TPT user, and how can we not include the Bronx