After talking with everyone in this post I have decided to go with the Fugeray. I'm only going to have a depth of about 10 inches between the substrate and the light. As long as I fertilize well and keep my CO2 up I am confident that the Fuge will grow a carpet. I don't have time to constantly be dealing with algae either.
Thank you all for your help. This board and more importantly the people on it are a great resource to the hobby.