The Planted Tank Forum

The Planted Tank Forum (http://www.plantedtank.net/forums/index.php)
-   Equipment (http://www.plantedtank.net/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=9)
-   -   Recommend a SILENT canister filter (http://www.plantedtank.net/forums/showthread.php?t=237466)

suprdave 02-07-2013 02:21 AM

Recommend a SILENT canister filter
 
Hi all,

I am still looking at replacing the HOB that my aqueon 36 gallon bowfront came with. It looks like the general consensus is that a canister filter is the way to go if you want silent. And by silent, I do mean silent - I don't want to hear it :)

I am having a hard time finding how exactly they work - is it essentially moving the motor that a HOB has inside the tank into the "canister" area, and you have a intake tube and an output tube? Appears that way, but I don't want to drop $100+ and find out it ain't gonna work for me.

This tank sits on a stand that is a couple feet high and 13" wide on both sides (separator in the middle), so most should fit in it it appears.

Thanks for the recommendations in advance!


Edit: This one has some pretty good reviews, and 4 pages of comments saying it's quiet: http://www.amazon.com/Aquatop-CF400U...rch_res_rtr_21

The Trigger 02-07-2013 02:44 AM

Get an Eheim or a fluval. I have an Eheim 2215 on my 29 and it is DEAD silent even after a few years. I think the Eheim classic series are literally the most simple design. Water goes in the bottom, is sucked upward through the multiple filtration stages and is piped out the top back into the tank. Once you actually see it for yourself you'll realize how easy it simple it actually is.

The Trigger 02-07-2013 02:45 AM

How simple it actually is*

fishwater 02-07-2013 03:21 AM

What the Trigger said! If you want quiet go with an Eheim.

Noahma 02-07-2013 03:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by suprdave (Post 2466162)
Hi all,

I am still looking at replacing the HOB that my aqueon 36 gallon bowfront came with. It looks like the general consensus is that a canister filter is the way to go if you want silent. And by silent, I do mean silent - I don't want to hear it :)

I am having a hard time finding how exactly they work - is it essentially moving the motor that a HOB has inside the tank into the "canister" area, and you have a intake tube and an output tube? Appears that way, but I don't want to drop $100+ and find out it ain't gonna work for me.

This tank sits on a stand that is a couple feet high and 13" wide on both sides (separator in the middle), so most should fit in it it appears.

Thanks for the recommendations in advance!


Edit: This one has some pretty good reviews, and 4 pages of comments saying it's quiet: http://www.amazon.com/Aquatop-CF400U...rch_res_rtr_21

I have one of the aquatop filters and it is dead absolutely dead quiet. it is a beast of a filter, about the size of a desk side trash bin lol which is not a bad thing

Dx3Bash 02-07-2013 03:56 AM

Have had Eheim, Fluval and Rena Filstars. All great filters and very quiet.

Yankee 02-07-2013 04:01 AM

Fluval is the only canister I've had and they're silent. You can find some older models for cheap. I've also heard the Renas are quiet for an economical filter.

rusty1760 02-07-2013 04:10 AM

I have an old Rena XP2 on my sons tank in his bedroom, it is almost totally silent and the build quality is great. The clips are nice and sturdy and snap into position beautifully. Not only that but the hoses are non kink silicon so stay nice and supple and don't harden or have a memory like most vinyl hose. I also have a Fluval 405 but would trade it for a Rena in a heart beat the quality is just not even close to the Rena

Cardoc 02-07-2013 04:19 AM

If you want no noise what so ever and the simplest filer and assuming you have some money to blow the fluval g3 or g6 is the way to go, it takes me less time to clean than my hob filters and gives you a bunch of good info like flow, temp., conductivity, time elapse on the mechanical, bio., and chemical filter change. Imo the best filter ever made, and I can tell you this thing is solid and will not leak. I have owned a bunch of filter and this is the best.

suprdave 02-07-2013 04:22 AM

Thanks for the feedback!

Sounds like I can't go wrong with any model.... The eheim recommendations echo what some other forums are saying as well.

I'm looking at this model in the 66 Gallon selection (for my 36 gallon tank - should be enough right? :P) http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00...seller=&sr=1-1

Another question... is the return water bar long enough on these to be able to get it either close enough to the water line where it won't make any noise? Or even better, under the water line? This tank is in the living room, so I am trying to minimize noise as much as possible on it.

TwoTacoCombo 02-07-2013 04:48 AM

I have an Eheim 2217, 2 2213s, a 2211, and an aquaclear 20 all in my 9'x14' office. The AC20 is by far the noisiest thing in here. Once an Eheim Classic settles in, the most it produces is a gentle hum and a little whooshing. The Eheims come with enough hose and a spray bar to put the outflow wherever you want. I have all of mine just under the surface of the water. Unless you point them upwards so that they lift water above the surface, this part of the system is totally silent. As far as sizing, you might want to just pony up for a 2217. Once your plants start growing, you'll find you need more flow than you expected.

suprdave 02-07-2013 05:04 AM

Thanks! I went with the 2215. The 2217 is not going to fit in the cabinet under the tank.

We'll see how she does!

Green_Flash 02-07-2013 07:54 AM

Eheim classics are pretty silent.

The Trigger 02-07-2013 01:30 PM

2215 was a good choice. It has never steered me wrong. As for the spray bar, I put mine about an inch or so under the water line and tip it up at about a 45 degree angle for a little bit of surface agitation. Makes no sound whatsoever

Landau 02-07-2013 03:33 PM

One quiet trick
 
My Fluval 205 was a bit noisy, not due to the filter directly but due to a resonance in the wall and stand floor.

I have an inline heater and some stiffer than standard tubing to it. This was transmitting some vibration from the filter to the wall behind the tank, producing a low hum. It was actually louder in the bedroom on the other side of the wall than in the aquarium room.

I used a few zip ties to hold the heater against the stand and off the wall, instantly much quieter. Next I put a small piece of carpet under the filter between it and the rather flimsy bottom shelf of my stand. All noise gone!


All times are GMT. The time now is 09:31 AM.

Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.