The Planted Tank Forum

The Planted Tank Forum (
-   Fish (
-   -   Purigen mistake! (

andygold 01-18-2013 02:33 AM

Purigen mistake!
Picked up a 100ml bag of Purigen. Since it came in a bag, and there is no smaller size, I rinsed it as per the instructions and then placed it upon the filter pad in my 3 gallon tank's filter.

Went out for about an hour and when I returned almost all of my guppies were either at the surface or on the bottom, barely moving, gills barely moving, and some had their mouths wide open.

A few were "stuck" in plants. The bigger the fish, the worse it was. All of the baby fish, snails and crab appeared unfazed. I immediately removed the Purigen. I noticed that the bottom of the bag was a cross between red and brown.

I ended up doing a water change figuring that there might have been some toxin released by the Purigen. Now, after rethinking the matter, I'm wondering if maybe the Purigen changed the water parameters extremely quickly. Possibly so quickly as to over stress the fish. Then again, maybe it's neither. I'm not sure why only the larger fish were affected. It reminded me of when one of my filters locked up, and stopped running, and I came home to dead fish. I guess that was due to lack of flow and oxygen starvation. It wasnt due to bacteria die off as the filter material sits above the tank, out of the water.

So although Purigen might be a good thing, it's probably not a good idea to use too much of it!

fplata 01-18-2013 02:38 AM

What kind of filter do you have?

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

NWA-Planted 01-18-2013 02:41 AM

No something else is wrong...

Purigen is basically like a regenerative activated carbon, except supposedly doesn't pull the vital minerals etc from the water.

It changes color when it's absorbing things from the water.

Thats really odd though, i would go about checking everything in the tank never hard purigen causing problems like this :-/

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2

Darkblade48 01-18-2013 02:49 AM

Very odd. I have used Purigen (without rinsing, even) and it has been fine.

Perhaps there is something else that is causing the problems? What are your water parameters like?

DarkCobra 01-18-2013 02:52 AM

Never heard of such a thing. Unless it's used Purigen which someone attempted to recycle with bleach, and then inadequately dechlorinated. Which will certainly cause these problems.

Was it new? Sealed packaging?

Jeff5614 01-18-2013 02:57 AM

Purigen does become toxic when used with an amine based dechlorinator if it comes in contact with chlorine.

laqu 01-18-2013 03:02 AM

i use purigen ALL the time never had a problem...

fplata 01-18-2013 03:22 AM

I wonder if you stopped the water flow on the filter when you placed the purigen bag in

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

CrypticLifeStyle 01-18-2013 02:30 PM

Curious what water conditioner do you use? I know products that are amine based can become toxic when used with purigen. Things happened too fast for it to be a infection of sorts. Definitely a chemical reaction

andygold 01-18-2013 03:22 PM

All the fish seem to be fine this morning. No deaths and none seem worse for wear. Last night though, even dumping in some Tetra flakes had them motionless.

To answer some questions...the filter is the standard filter that comes with the Marineland Eclipse 3 gallon tank. It is a above the tank/under the hood style. It has a power head that pumps water across the top of a filter floss cartridge that then drips through to the carbon/charcoal below and then that falls over a bio-wheel, and back into the tank. I have modded the cartidge to make it reusable, in that I peeled up the floss from the frame and replaced the stock carbon with a known brand and also added some zeolite in a roughly 50/50 mix. Where the standard cartidge is about 10 percent filled with media, it is now 100% filled with my mixture. This was last changed at the beginning of the month. i also have a Tom's internal filter with a block of foam sitting below a media chamber, which is also filled with my own carbon. This was changed a few days before the introduction to Purigen.

The Purigen changed color where it was touching the filter pad. It went from it's stock sandy color to red and brown in a few places. This was within one hour of application. yes, it was sitting on a dirty filter pad, but the pad had been rinsed and brushed maybe a week and ahalf earlier (in siphoned tank water). Pad was relatively clean at the time with good flow throughout.

Purigen was brand new, bought online, but from a vendor new to myself (Phenter Sales $4.95 for 100ml). It appears to be new, was in a heat sealed bag inside the box, with an instruction sheet). Having never used the stuff before, I thought it strange that even after wetting it, it still appeared to be dry, but I'm assuming that it does not absorb liquid, but instead adsorbs organics. I'm assuming that it's legit and brand new. I've not had to recharge it as it is new, and it did not have any odor. I've also not used amine based dechlor in well over a year.

Water parameters...gonna get flamed here!!! Bioload is immense!!! 3 gallon tank. 12 full grown fancy guppies 9a few more females than males), about the same amount of babies 1/4" to 3/4" length. Every day I seem to have more new borns as they typically give birth to a few per day, and the birthing process lasts for a few days for each female. Many, many have remarked that my guppies are the largest guppies they've ever seen. I've got newborns pretty much every day! I'm at the LFS giving away fish every week :)
There's also about a dozen or so adult Malaysian Trumpet Snails, but another dozen or two or three babies. Also, 4 Nerite Snails (egg laying everywhere), and a small red-clawed crab.

As my PH levels are always falling weekily into the below 7 range from my tap water of 8.2- 8.4, I do a once or twice weekly water change of about 33% (1 gallon changed out of 3, by way of a gravel vac siphon).
So, my fish are quite used to PH swings. No ick, no disease, no deaths, just non-stop breeding.
Water is very soft. About 10ppm from the tap, but typically verrrry high in the tank (400->999ppm) depending on when I test. Again, all inhabitants seem to be used to this and appear to getting on without issue.

No copper, no nothing, other than Prime, Flourish (1 drop every day to two days), the occasional bacterial supplement if I feel the need to do a big cleaning, and some API salt (1/2 tsp/gallon) somewhat often when doing a water change (not during top-ups). Even the few floating plants are growing like crazy.

i guess it is possible that the bag of Purigen might have caused a dam atop the filter pad, preventing water from flowing across the full surface of said pad, but the bio-wheel was still spinning at its normal rate, and the purigen was discolored almost totally along it's bottom side where it had been resting upon the filter pad. I'm going to assume that if the pad was having a blockage and bacteria were dieing, then I would have seen rapid gilling and other symptoms of oxygen starvation/toxicity. The fish' gills were barely moving, and my guppies are somewhat translucent, like ghost shrimp, but not entirely clear (translucent bodies, bright orange tails-females) I can see their gills and they were not red. The fish appeared to be sleeping in the light, or doped up. Maybe the Purigen got them high :)

Edit: forgot to add, I've got a small piece if cuttlebone on top of the filter pad that was in contact with a small part of the Purigen bag. I also throw about 1/4 piece of a Tums (the stuff used for heartburn) into the tank a couple times a month to add some harness to the water, and help with snail and crab shell erosion.

tiggity 01-18-2013 03:28 PM

Kind of odd with Purigen, I have 2 100ml bags for my 37g and that's too much I think. However, I don't have any issues when I 1st put the bags in or after regeneration.

I'm probably thinking like others have mentioned, possibly the type of dechlorinator you are using.

edit: NVM on the dechlorinator, you mentioned Prime and that stuff is awesome with Purigen.

devilduck 01-18-2013 04:11 PM

I've used and re-charged my purigen for years without a problem. Something was definitely off with your batch.

shloken38 01-18-2013 06:51 PM


Originally Posted by Jeff5614 (Post 2274817)
Purigen does become toxic when used with an amine based dechlorinator if it comes in contact with chlorine.

This is interesting....what did you rinse that bag with? Was it tap water? Could it be possible that your tap water has a decent amount of chlorine in it?

CrypticLifeStyle 01-18-2013 06:54 PM

You have a lot going on in a 3 gallon tank lol. Go to seachems main page forum, and run the scenario by them. They are pretty good at answering posts.

somewhatshocked 01-18-2013 08:04 PM

Your tap water in Northern Kentucky - unless it's from a well, and even then I'm doubting how soft it is - is quite hard. That region isn't the greatest on the water front. Do you have GH & KH readings from a liquid test kit?

I doubt strongly that it was the Purigen causing a problem. You've likely stirred up something in the tank or filter and caused a mini cycle to hit.

All times are GMT. The time now is 05:27 AM.

Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2016, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2016 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.