The Planted Tank Forum

The Planted Tank Forum (http://www.plantedtank.net/forums/index.php)
-   Shrimp & Other Invertebrates (http://www.plantedtank.net/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=88)
-   -   Pond snail? (http://www.plantedtank.net/forums/showthread.php?t=199514)

Steelwolve 12-06-2012 02:27 AM

Pond snail?
 
After reading about pond snails from a few internet sources Im a bit confused/skeptical about what Ive read. First, I did learn that my snail population is part of my bio load. It seems obvious but I really hadnt considered it in the past. Now heres where im confused, every thing I read says that overfeeding is what makes the population explode. Well Ive had a low tech 10g planted set up now for 3 months. Got the snails pretty much right off the bat from plants, and the population was massive in the 1st month and has not declined at all. This tank has no other life in it and I have not put a drop of food into the tank since its start. It is a Dirted tank, MGOCPM, capped with sand. The tank did cycle through an algae phase, but bounced back quickly. My thinking was that the snails were eating my diatoms, and hair algae. But it hasnt had any algae now for 2 months (besides a couple small BBA outbreaks) So at this point whats keeping these buggers numbers so high? I dont really mind a few, in fact I havent tried removing them yet at all, because my 10G low tech is doing and looking way better than my 29g and 90g high tech on the cheap tanks. BUT I would like to take their numbers down quite a bit, mainly for aesthetic reasons. I thought this would happen naturally after the algae was eaten away, I guess not. Whats your thoughts are they surviving off new algae growth that gets eaten so fast I dont notice it??? or maybe off something in the soil?? Also, are there any small 2"max fish that would eat pond snails, or at least a few snailets?

Crob5965 12-06-2012 02:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steelwolve (Post 2100878)
After reading about pond snails from a few internet sources Im a bit confused/skeptical about what Ive read. First, I did learn that my snail population is part of my bio load. It seems obvious but I really hadnt considered it in the past. Now heres where im confused, every thing I read says that overfeeding is what makes the population explode. Well Ive had a low tech 10g planted set up now for 3 months. Got the snails pretty much right off the bat from plants, and the population was massive in the 1st month and has not declined at all. This tank has no other life in it and I have not put a drop of food into the tank since its start. It is a Dirted tank, MGOCPM, capped with sand. The tank did cycle through an algae phase, but bounced back quickly. My thinking was that the snails were eating my diatoms, and hair algae. But it hasnt had any algae now for 2 months (besides a couple small BBA outbreaks) So at this point whats keeping these buggers numbers so high? I dont really mind a few, in fact I havent tried removing them yet at all, because my 10G low tech is doing and looking way better than my 29g and 90g high tech on the cheap tanks. BUT I would like to take their numbers down quite a bit, mainly for aesthetic reasons. I thought this would happen naturally after the algae was eaten away, I guess not. Whats your thoughts are they surviving off new algae growth that gets eaten so fast I dont notice it??? or maybe off something in the soil?? Also, are there any small 2"max fish that would eat pond snails, or at least a few snailets?


I went through the same thing with my 55 dirted I finally bought some assassin snails it hasnt solved the problem but it has definatley helped control the problem I usually remove 10-15 a week now during water changes instead of 100 a week :)

Newman 12-06-2012 03:05 AM

they pretty much eat everything including most organic stuff in your substrate, your decaying plants, driftwood, leaves. so you are overfeeding them and just don't know it ;)

once they get really established and get everywhere (substrate, filter, underside of your lid) you can't get rid of them except w/o a predator or a chemical means which is not advisable.

best thing to have done was to remove them from the start. planted tanks w/o snails do exist. i am sure you can get there if you want.

inthepacific 12-06-2012 03:23 AM

i also found pond snails. the really came out of nowehere and grew to full size in less than a few days and already finding babies. but i plan on getting a small tank for a pea puffer and just feeding them to it.

golfer_d 12-08-2012 05:12 PM

I have the same issue here with my 10 gallon. Came in on a plant I got and BOOM they are everywhere now.

I want to get rid of most but not all as I plan to have a pea puffer tank at the start of the new year.

Will 1 assassin snail help reduce the number enough??

Crob5965 12-09-2012 01:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by golfer_d (Post 2103418)
I have the same issue here with my 10 gallon. Came in on a plant I got and BOOM they are everywhere now.

I want to get rid of most but not all as I plan to have a pea puffer tank at the start of the new year.

Will 1 assassin snail help reduce the number enough??

you'll still have to do some work yourself but you will notice a difference within a week.

I have a 55 gal with 2 so I have to think a 10 gal would be good with 1-2


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:11 PM.

Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.