|Topic Review (Newest First)|
|01-24-2009 01:10 PM|
Nice list. Remember folks, that a rule that holds "for the most part" is a rule nonetheless.
|01-23-2009 11:07 PM|
My favorite do would be: "Do break the rules when appropriate."
The problem is, you have to understand the reasons for the rules to know how to appropriately break them. That's what elevates it to an art form.
|01-22-2009 09:18 PM|
|rountreesj||Now I feel bad...I didn't mean any of ^^^that to be hatefull, just helpfull|
|01-22-2009 09:15 PM|
What's the point of aquascaping if you don't go for specifics?
the op said rules for "aquascaping" not "a planted tank"...
|01-22-2009 09:09 PM|
I read it and was like..."well to make ANY of my dream scapes, I would probably follow most, if not all, of these rules". Than I read a lot of the nay sayers' thoughts and it kinda agrivated me(not a lot...just a little).
Yes it is your tank and by all means do what you like with it. But show me one amano scape that doesn't follow these rules. And that being said...show me one amano scape you wouldnt put anywhere in your house.
That being said...yes there are some rules that can be broken or twisted, but most of these ideas rules have been formed over time and have been proven to work pretty well. I see tanks a lot of times and I think "if only the'd remove that huge plant" or "man if they just slope a little more" or "man what plant do they NOT have..." etc...
The point I guess I'm trying to make is don't call the original poster out for not seeing everyone's personal taste in aquascaping...because deep down... I think most of the experienced aquascapers accept and practice these rules... There is an art to aquascaping, and just like painting or sculptin, you CAN do whatever you like...but most of the really "great" works are created following the rules that apply to that form of art...
Sorry if I stepped on anyone's toes...just had to put my two cents in...
|01-21-2009 12:34 AM|
I like this thread a lot. I am new to aquascaping, I have kept plants in my tanks for years real low tech.
It is great to have suggestions like these here, and I like hearing not everyone is following the rules to T. I most certainly threw things together willy nilly in my tank and am learning as I go. I will always keep it the way I like it not the way the "book" says as per say. I guess if I was in contests and things then I would be more technical about my aquascape otherwise I am fine with it looking good to "me" .or even just me.
|01-20-2009 09:52 PM|
Originally Posted by Complexity View Post
|01-20-2009 09:47 PM|
I just have to compliment the type of people that are on this forum. I think this thread speaks volumes about the kindness and sophistication of the planted tank crowd. After the first few critiques of this thread, many people came back (mostly those who had critiqued) with reassurance that Lee's ideas were helpful, appreciated, and most of all, uniquely her's. (or his? )
I have read this same type of support, time and time again on TPT. I think that's why it's so easy to spend hours scrolling these pages.
Sorry to get all cheesy, but this is just very refreshing after seeing peoples AWFUL hate-filled comments on larger sites like youtube.
Just my 2 cents.....
|01-19-2009 08:32 AM|
|airborne_r6||I think it is very helpful toward identifying why something looks good and why something else just doesnt look right. I definitely agree that individual satisfaction is the most important element when designing a layout and the basic things outlined here can give someone with no experience like me a good place to start.|
|01-09-2009 09:40 AM|
|Lee||Ok, thanks guys. I will post some more aquascaping ideas later. But first I'm going to see how my tank turns out using these techniques.|
|01-09-2009 06:06 AM|
|sewingalot||Great list for beginners wanting to know what to shoot for and what rules to break. Good job. I think I hit on at least 19 of the don'ts though.|
|01-08-2009 12:15 AM|
|Gr8_Laker||Thanks Lee! I am working on my 'scape and wish I had seen this earlier. It's the concepts that are important, and judging my tank against your list helps me understand where I might need improvement.|
|01-07-2009 11:28 PM|
|wug||I think this was very helpful. My second hobby is bonsai. And it like aquascaping is an artform. There are general guidelines in bonsai that people follow to make a tree look good. But, again it is subject to personal taste. I appreciate you posting this.|
|01-07-2009 03:38 PM|
|brinks||Lee I think that list like yours are helpful, if only to get other people to post their thoughts. I am sure we are all smart enough to know which of the do's and don'ts we want to follow. As I have only one tank, I bend the rules often, because I like to try different plants and see how they do, you never know when you will find a good one. Haven't had much luck with red, so I have distroyed don't #4, lol.|
|01-07-2009 03:45 AM|
|Gatekeeper||#4 on the "don't list" is thrown out the door on the first picture. Tank looks banging to me.|
|This thread has more than 15 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.|