There is heated debate as to weither this moss can survive for long under water.
The most common source of this moss is from Aquaticmagic on Ebay or Aquabid. If anyone has kept it alive submersed for more than a few months, please tell us the specs of the tank. Lighting, tank size, CO2 or not, PH, temperature, dosing...
I got it from Aquatic Magic.
The ones in the picture are either way bigger than the ones i got or the shrimp is SUPER small.
I recieved them in the mail around the 22 of April (just over 2 weeks).
They are still dark green no new growth that i can see, no die off that i can see either.
I will keep you posted about the growth.
I also got mine April of this year. Just added a picture. It seem growing but not sure for how long. It's not as nice as the onces in there site (Mine is definitely UGLY) but its definitely growing upwards.
ok so i neglected the tank that was holding these and it has since turned a little brown. so hopefully i will be able to bring it back
oh yea i want to CSULB Japanese wateer garden and saw some of this around the roots of a bonsai tree
It Is Not........a true aquatic.
I visit the sierra nevada mountains weekly and I see this moss grown in dry places. They do not grow submerged, though it would be nice to have a submerged species like this
I seen this moss growing in Wyoming forest, and i also bought some from aquamagic as well, same picture. It never grew, and eventually fell apart and made a huge mess. Ill post a pic of the one i saw in Wyoming.
Just got some off this off eBay from our friends at AquaMagic. Ordered it back in January and got it just this week (mid June). Fortunately I only put it in a small quarantine tank, just wish I had been smart enough to Google the plant name in the first place. At least the other two plants I ordered check out.
I bought some of this 2 or 3 months ago. Nice and green when it went in the tank but went brown over a period of 1-2 weeks, and I thought I'd lost it. Never got around to taking it out though and now (4 - 6 weeks later) I've got some new growth showing on it. I'm not overly hopeful about how well it's gonna do but I'm going to leave and see what happens!
I bought some of this recently -also from Aquaticmagic on no ebay links allowed I was buying something else from them and thought "why not??" Arrived towards the end of December. I tied it to some driftwood and it did start to sprout a little fairly quickly (was very flat and dormant looking when it arrived) but has since done not much of anything. I guess we'll see.
The pic on the left is star moss.The one on the right is most definitely not.Most mosses sold by eBay sellers including Aqua-bid are not suitable for tropical set ups.Many aren't true aquatic species either.Many of them are semi aquatic meaning they do well partially submerged some but not all of the time.I live in the Pacific Northwest, which seems to be home to every moss on the planet .Ive tried several that are growing all around me including those I find growing below water depth in my local creek.Its not surprising to read just how many people get burned on buying these mosses when they're not even native to tropical environments or can adapt to being submerged.The ones Ive had success with ,are in non heated tanks,med to low lighting ,no CO2 ,slow water movement.As with any plant that is filament like in leaf structure, care must be taken to make sure they're not covered with algae or any detritus,dirt etc.Ive successfully kept this particular plant alive and well for over 2 years without any major issues.
I received this star Moss from Aquatic Magic on eBay it took about 2 to 3 weeks received the a star Moss. Has been in my 55 gallon tank attached to it piece of driftwood for about two months. The tank is high/medium light, temperature 76°, fertilizer once a day. At this time it started to die back there is only a little bit of green sprouts noted at the very top and around edges of the plastic netting that it came attached to. To me like everybody else is saying that this is a non-aquatic plant will not grow in fully submerged in water. I will leave it in the tank and see what happens and if it starts to grow back I will report back on the results. I would like to shake the person's hands who grows this star Moss submerged in water.
Surely not submerged moss. You can see everywhere in here Hong Kong but except water... it can grow in the water about 3cm. But cant reproduce. good for terrariums etc. Not for really planted aquariums
I saw this moss in nature at Kerala, India. I collected lots of it. But at all locations, it was only growing on rocks. It was well implanted there and very less sunlight reached those spots. The temperature for that location is between 16 deg Cel to 26 deg cel. I did not see this moss under water anywhere in that location. Even where there were tiny streams of water, it was only growing on sheer walls, rocks and mountains not directly exposed to sunlight.
I contacted AquaticMagic for advice on growing my star moss. Here's the reply I got: "Star moss is not aquatic by nature. However, it is absolute possible to have it growing submerged, healthily. One trick is that, grow it on a alkaline stone/rock instead of drift wood. It prefers rocks than wood." I think I will try this, but can anyone recommend what would be a good aquarium stone that is alkaline? I might consider harvesting this stuff in a separate tank in a more humid emersive environment and then transferring periodically to my show tank.
Question... Is there anything that is both a dry land plant AND an aquatic plant ? I asked this because this plant grows quite a bit around where I live. But it grows in damp very humid parts of the forest almost exclusively next to but not in stream. Seems to prefer being on top of tree roots just as they branch off of the tree going into the ground. But often found on top of the ground all around such as what was just described. The typical soil being tan, an indication of high iron content.
I see this stuff growing on rocks nowhere near water in the forests of south NY state. I also see it growing in bog areas well above the water line. I have never once seen it growing below the water line, and have seen it die in the bogs when the streams flood. It is simply not an aquatic moss. As far as growing on an alkaline rock, don't bother, as that rock with throw off your ph and the moss will still die. I usually see it growing on granite if growing on stone at all.