The Planted Tank Forum - View Profile: Hoppy

Hoppy Hoppy is offline

Planted Tank Guru

  Visitor Messages

Showing Visitor Messages 141 to 150 of 193
  1. Doc7
    07-01-2011 02:58 PM - permalink
    As luck would have it, Amazon has them
  2. Doc7
    06-30-2011 10:19 PM - permalink
    Cannot and will not argue! That seems great then. Hopefully I can find two of the coralife 36 inch fixtures ; I can replace the bulbs with any brand so going out of business doesn't matter right? Is a reflector from say a catalina 4 bulb t5ho fixture (with t5NO bulbs) going to be signifcantly brighter or should it still be in that 40 mms range you recommend? I can get a custom fixture there but are their reflectors "too good" for a four bulb spread?
  3. Hoppy
    06-29-2011 10:13 PM - permalink
    Look at some of Tom Barr's (Plantbrain) tanks. Those are now all running at 40 mms of PAR or less. He uses high CO2, very high surface rippling, and other tactics to get high O2 levels in his tanks. Then, he grows whatever plants he wants to grow, and sells the excess regularly. I can't see any way to argue with that success.
  4. Doc7
    06-29-2011 07:16 PM - permalink
    That seems like a pretty low PAR, even for low light tank. I do know you recommend low light. I am ready and willing - in fact eager - to use the dual stage CO2 system I just finished and wonder if there is a way to take more advantage but still in that low/medium sweet spot.
  5. Hoppy
    06-29-2011 03:20 PM - permalink
    A 40 breeder tank is about 16 inches high. If you have 3 inches of substrate, and the bulbs are about an inch above the top of the tank, they will be about 14 inches from the substrate. A Coralife 2 bulb T5NO light should give you about 40 mms of PAR at that distance. If you use two of them spread about 8 inches or so apart, you should get pretty uniform 40 mms PAR over the whole substrate. Unfortunately it is hard to find any Coralife T5NO lights now. You could do without CO2 with that light level, but Excel would help the plants a lot.
  6. Doc7
    06-29-2011 02:22 PM - permalink
    The feline situation has convinced me to re-look at the whole picture here and after reviewing many of your comments in the past again, now I am back to thinking about a T5NO, 2 bulb wide-spread setup in a canopy. then I don't need to mess with anything between the lights and water and there will be defense against the cat going in which is win win.

    I have a 2 bulb T5NO already on my 20 gallon High (16 inch height, 12 inches wide) and it certainly doesn't seem too bright to me although I have no PAR meter. It is a coralife which has mixed reflector reviews. I am struggling to convince myself that the same number of bulbs, but spread out 8 inches from one another in a bigger fixture, will provide good lighting for growth. Does that bring me to the equivalent of 1 T5NO for most substrate areas?
  7. Hoppy
    06-28-2011 03:31 PM - permalink
    I have never tested the use of "egg crate" versus light intensity. Intuitively I think it will reduce the PAR about 30-50%, even directly under the light, and more further away from the center of the light, but that is largely a guess. (A spot directly under the light gets light from a pretty long length of the bulbs, but the "egg crate" stops the light from much of that length, which should reduce the PAR directly under the bulb.) I doubt that there is much, if any difference between 10" and 11" wide fixtures.
  8. Doc7
    06-28-2011 01:42 PM - permalink
    [FONT=Arial]I can get a 2 x T5HO custom Catalina fixture in either 10” or 11” wide (which must be used for their 3/4/6 bulb units) for a comparable price to the Hagen GLO etc fixtures and less than 50% of the price of getting a 4 bulb fixture (TEK etc) and not using 2 of the bulbs. This seems like a great way to increase the spread over an 18” wide 40-breeder tank.

    A recent change; I will be using egg crate over the tank to prevent feline intrusion. I understand that egg crate re-directs stray light with an increase in PAR directly beneath the bulbs yet a decrease in PAR as horizontal distance from the bulb grows. Do you think 2 bulbs in either 10” or 11” fixture, will be able to be raised to an “optimal” height such that I had the relatively even low-to-moderate light you recommend w/ CO2 dosing/EI? See any reason to use 10” vs 11”?

    Thanks much for all the help you provide.
  9. Hoppy
    06-17-2011 01:39 AM - permalink
    I have various photos of tanks I have had, and setups I have had, but my 3 tanks now are all in a state of need for a lot of loving care. I get preoccupied with my projects and neglect them. And, in a few months I hope to be moving, where I may not be able to have any tanks, which dampens my current enthusiasm.
  10. amberskye
    06-17-2011 12:41 AM - permalink
    ..passing through ...

  About Me

  • About Hoppy
    Sacramento, CA
  • Signature


Total Posts
Visitor Messages
General Information
  • Last Activity: 04-28-2016 08:43 PM
  • Join Date: 12-23-2005
  • Referrals: 4


Showing Friends 1 to 10 of 59
  • !shadow!
    • !shadow! is offline
  • AmazonTank
    • AmazonTank is offline
  • amberskye
    • amberskye is offline
  • anastasisariel
    • anastasisariel is offline
  • averittexpress
    • averittexpress is offline
  • BigCountry
    • BigCountry is offline
  • Black Hills Tj
    • Black Hills Tj is offline
  • brion0
    • brion0
    • Planted Tank Obsessed
    • brion0 is offline
  • bsmith
    • bsmith is offline
  • Casardo
    • Casardo is offline


02:04 AM - Audionut mentioned Hoppy in post Wrapping my head around KH and co2. Led light questions! Look!
... Minor correction Hoppy. That would be Bica...
12:39 AM - Audionut mentioned Hoppy in post CO2, pH, and dKH question observation from Hoppy. The last paragraph...
01:32 AM - burr740 mentioned Hoppy in post Lighting an Aquarium with PAR instead of Watts
...hat one was made by Hoppy (thanks again man, i...


09:09 PM - Hooked on fish quoted Hoppy in post 2x Dose Exel?
I do see much better plant...
03:30 AM - redranger quoted Hoppy in post Plants grow like crazy after water change but not when I dose Leaf zone or root tabs?
What lighting are you usin...
07:33 PM - Hoppy quoted AlanLe in post Miracle Grow Vs. Aquasoil
How do you replace the soil...
07:29 PM - Hoppy quoted alcimedes in post Can you get sick from mineralizing soil?
Baking won't work. You'd have...
03:03 PM - alcimedes quoted Hoppy in post Can you get sick from mineralizing soil?
You can mineralize soil by...
01:59 AM - Hoppy quoted mikluha in post Will Plants stop consuming nitrates if trace elements are not there?
Redfield ratio (N:P=16:1) he...
12:01 AM - jonnythe quoted Hoppy in post Amount of CO2 in Air Bubbles
I know that the 3 ppm valu...
12:00 AM - AWolf quoted Hoppy in post Amount of CO2 in Air Bubbles
...pheric air. Thanks Hoppy. That would support...
11:31 PM - Hoppy quoted Mango in post Interesting survey
Complete the survey below ...
07:59 PM - jonnythe quoted Hoppy in post Amount of CO2 in Air Bubbles
An air bubble rising throu...
03:00 PM - AWolf quoted Hoppy in post Amount of CO2 in Air Bubbles
The amount of CO2 and O2 f...
02:24 PM - Hoppy quoted AWolf in post Amount of CO2 in Air Bubbles
An air bubble rising throu...
05:26 AM - AlanLe quoted Hoppy in post Miracle Grow Vs. Aquasoil
The original Aquasoil Amaz...
06:23 AM - supahenzi quoted Hoppy in post Finnex Heads UP!
You don't need an airstone...
01:52 AM - AWolf quoted Hoppy in post Amount of CO2 in Air Bubbles
Yes, it does add CO2 to th...
09:47 PM - Drewet88 quoted Hoppy in post GH & KH Questions
Eheim Surface Skimmer does...
04:35 AM - Ukelay1 quoted Hoppy in post Fertilisers
If you have a high light t...
04:26 AM - MysticalBeast5623 quoted Hoppy in post Deleted Posts
08:48 PM - Hoppy quoted max88 in post Read the dosing guide... my head hurts..
I've read this everywhere,...
12:46 AM - burr740 quoted Hoppy in post Miracle Grow Vs. Aquasoil
The original Aquasoil Amaz...

  Feedback Score

iTrader Profile Recent Ratings
Feedback Score:
Positive Feedback:
Members who left positive:
Members who left negative:
Total positive feedback: 85
Submit Feedback
6 Months
12 Months
Positive Positive 0 2 3
Neutral Neutral 0 0 0
Negative Negative 0 0 0
For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome