The Planted Tank Forum - View Single Post - Lighting Advice 6' long x 2' deep
View Single Post
post #7 of (permalink) Old 01-10-2017, 01:59 PM Thread Starter
Chadmanfoo
Algae Grower
 
Join Date: Jan 2017
Posts: 11
Quote:
Originally Posted by jellopuddinpop View Post
I'm also trying to light a 72" tank, and I'm going to be going with 2 "Standard Doubles" from Dustinsfishtanks.com. I've been watching his youtube channel for years, and he really knows his stuff. He also offers the "Blaster Series", which was designed for depths up to 30". I don't have the lights yet, but will be getting them when I set up my 120G in the spring.

Lights ? Dustin?s Fishtanks
I would be dubious to part with my money until I had seen some more reviews on these. The Kelvin rating seems a little low, although i have to admit, 2 x 72" would be better than 4 x 36" from a cost perspective. Could be an expensive mistake if they were no good however.

Quote:
Originally Posted by DaveK View Post
When you get into tanks 72 inches long that are 24 inches deep you likely have a tank that is 18 or 24 inches wide. This is a lot of area to cover. You will also likely have a center brace on the tank.

With LED your going to have two general options. Use strip lighting, similar to what you have, or go with pendant lighting. If you have a center brace, you go with 4 to 6, 36 inch strip lights. If you go with pendants, you go with 2, 3 or 4 pendants. I don't recommend 3 if the tank has a center brace.

Now you have additional considerations. LED lighting likes to go straight down. Depending on the arrangement of everything, this can leave you with dark corners or ends in the tank, and dark areas near the surface. This is on thing I don't like at all, and why I like multiple fixtures for the tank. Generally, I think you get better results with more, but lessor wattage fixtures. This can have a cost problem because two smaller wattage fixtures can often cost a lot more than one large wattage fixture.

You might be able to find lighting that will span a 6 foot tank, or build a canopy to do this, but I find this solution to be really awkward for working on the tank. Think about needing to remove it for major work. (grin)

Now it gets really tricky. There are a lot of good LED fixtures available both in pendants and strip lights. You need to make your selection based upon your budget, and what you want out of the lighting. You are also going to see lots of recommendations, mostly people recommending the fixture they bought. While I'm sure they love their lighting, for a lot of them, it's only the first or second LED lighting they ever bought, so they are not often objective.

At this point, I can tell you that I use two Current USA Satellite LED + PRO fixtures on my 90 gal (4 feet long) planted tank. I like the light I get, but I find the set up of the controller to be a real pain, and somewhat limited in function. If I were using them on a 6 foot tank, I'd use 4, 36 inch fixtures. This would have a downside. You would need to set up each fixture individually. If I were doinf this again, and money was no object, I think I'd go with EcoTech pendants or Kessil pendants. They would cost lots more, but they can be connected together and controlled from a single point.

Lastly, you can use the LED lighting made for reef systems, if you can dial back the blues, but this is a very expensive solution, and your paying for a lot of blue light you will not use. Shop carefully.
Thanks DaveK. That is more information that i could have hoped for.

Since the tank will have a solid oak hood with about 4" clearance from the glass cover, i think the pendants are probably not going to work unless i sit them on the glass. I will probably need to go for 4 x 36" strips in that case. I intend to buy purpose built for a planted setup and just have them on a timer, so individual programming shouldn't be an issue.

With this in mind, would you personally recommend the Sat LED+ Pro? I was thinking about the Finnex Fugeray Planted+ since it incorporate the true red 660nm, but 4 of these would set me back around £500. I am willing to pay this if I am certain they will be sufficient.

Last edited by Darkblade48; 01-10-2017 at 02:48 PM. Reason: dupe post
Chadmanfoo is online now  
 
 
For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome