Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Indianapolis, IN
NW Indy here. I have been frequenting The Reef because they are pretty much the only LFS where you can get plants and "less common" freshwater fish. I have gotten good advice there as well. They have decent prices on fish and plants. Maybe a little higher on consumables and hardware, but they don't have the buying power of a Petsmart or Petco. The Reef is my go-to for specialty items. If they weren't across town, I'd be in there a lot more. I've also bought fish at Petsmart and had good luck as well, but the selection is fairly pedestrian.
Also, what's this club previously mentioned? The Facebook link was broken.