Whoops hit enter, 4am lol. The reason that dog training is so controversial imo is because people don't like to admit when they are wrong and have a hard time evolving. I highly recommend reading the book, when pigs fly by Jane killion, it is all about using clicker training with stubborn dogs.
In any case humane to me is respect and a desire to minimise suffering.
Sent from my Nexus S using Tapatalk 2